Oil Color

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 10, 2006
Messages
139
Location
New York
I have been reading a lot of posts here related to oil color. The general conclusion is oil color did not have anything to do with how well or how clean your oil or engine is. I just ran across something interesting the other day. I just got my oil change couple day ago and when I checked my oil, it is very nice and clean and had a light brown color on the dipstick. It looks just like the oil in the GTX bottle before I poured it in the engine. This weekend, I decided to do an Auto-rx cleaning on the car and I put in 10ozs of Auto-rx in the engine. The next day after I drove the car a little bit and then checked the oil to make sure it is not overfill. The oil looks pretty black and I remenbered when I was pouring the Auto-rx into the engine.,the color of the arx cleaner coming out of the bottle is black. So I decided to take a look at what arx will affect the oil color. Here is what I did. I took 2 quarts of Castrol GTX 5W30 dino oil and pour 2ozs of arx in one of them to simulate when I just put into my engine (10ozs for a 5 quarts capacity) and then shake the bottle to mix it up and here is the result. The GTX bottle with the 2ozs of arx became so dark/black that you can no longer see through it under any light. I took a picture of it with them side by side but I don't know how to post it with this message (Can someone show me how to post a picture here?). I found that very interesting since at the end of an arx cleaning, the oil almost always look black when you drain it out, but if you look at the picture, the new oil became black the moment that I pour the arx into the new GTX bottle. That tells me I wouldn't know how clean my engine is until after the rinsing cycle is completed. You can't tell by looking at the oil color to determine how clean your engine is.
stirthepot.gif
 
Good job for taking initiative and doing that experiment. The cleaning dosage ratio for Auto-RX is ~5% and it sure does darken virgin oil as I have found too. I agree with your conclusion in your last sentence.
 
Or if you like to start out with colored oil you could alway's use TRC's Moly XL Pro-Spec oil. It's blue. I guess it's the moly package that makes it blue?

Blue Oil!

Then there's Royal Purple. It starts out purple dosen't it.
 
i use smell to determine oil quality virgin oil has a nice refreshing smell... when my oil starts smelling like gas it gets changed on my honda i change it every 3 months or 15000 kilometers. i use that car quite a bit
 
Obviously, then, oil color is no indicator of life left in this case. Or seldom is it, IMHO. Short of UOA it's all guessing, and what can a body guess about used oil but color or smell and what it means?

Short of doing the ARX treatment and tearing down your engine to see if it's done any good, the only thing we non-techs can do check the filter element for chunks & goobers.

The rest is making yourself feel good by telling yourself how thoughtful and caring you are to your car by spending more money on it. That, and guessing what's going on by the oil color like a bunch of old farmers discussing the weather over coffee in the morning.

After all, how much can oil color tell us when some oils are good for 8000 miles or more and they looks/smell like #@$%! after 5000 miles?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom