Not surprised in VT or NH

Seems like poor planning (given for people) as they were warned and lack of infrastructure in NH, VT, ME to support extraordinary peak times.

Still considering a used EV for commuting with free charging at work place.

https://www.wcvb.com/article/tesla-...harge-cars-after-total-solar-eclipse/60448157
Vermont, rather famously, closed their nuclear plant, and imports most of their electricity from Hydroquebec, as part of a green agenda. The electric supply is supplanted by large solar investments, in what is the cloudiest state in the Union. Vermont electricity supply is bizarre, as a result. The electric vehicle penetration is, not surprisingly, rather modest. There are not a lot of chargers, and the state itself is only 650,000 people, so, it’s like the population of, well, Virginia Beach, in terms of infrastructure scale - so it comes as no surprise that the electric infrastructure was overwhelmed by the number of people descending on them for the eclipse.
 
It’s the USPS conundrum. USPS is required to deliver mail on unprofitable routes, ones that UPS and others will not.

In the states mentioned there are many such routes. That would imply it would not be that feasible as well to have widespread charging.

The USPS is mandated to make a profit, yet they do not. In private scenarios shareholders and the board have a say. My .02 VT was where I wanted to start my career in the 90’s but the pay was so low and the rent relatively high. I knew every Volvo indie from Bennington to the Canadian border and I really loved the state back then. Even joined Vt 251 and straddled the border with one foot in the US and one in Canada in a library…
 
I'm 50 miles away from Philly and Balt and we don't have many chargers here. Even the free VW charging deal wouldn't work...
Hybrids are what we need today, not EVs
I work in a 19 story 2019 constructed building, with free EV charging. There was so little demand, in the garage they had to open up 2/3 of the charging parking spaces to everyone by changing the signs that said EV only. This is in Phila. So how can such be properly planned in VT?
 
I work in a 19 story 2019 constructed building, with free EV charging. There was so little demand, in the garage they had to open up 2/3 of the charging parking spaces to everyone by changing the signs that said EV only. This is in Phila. So how can such be properly planned in VT?
We had two chargers put in around 12 miles from me..after 1 year they removed them.
 
Vermont, rather famously, closed their nuclear plant, and imports most of their electricity from Hydroquebec, as part of a green agenda. The electric supply is supplanted by large solar investments, in what is the cloudiest state in the Union. Vermont electricity supply is bizarre, as a result. The electric vehicle penetration is, not surprisingly, rather modest. There are not a lot of chargers, and the state itself is only 650,000 people, so, it’s like the population of, well, Virginia Beach, in terms of infrastructure scale - so it comes as no surprise that the electric infrastructure was overwhelmed by the number of people descending on them for the eclipse.
The State of Vermont did not "close its nuclear plant" Its owner, Entergy, did so as a business decision. The plant competed on the New England grid along with all other generation suppliers. The plant required a refueling, which would have been a $70 million commitment by the owner. The owner decided, based on its projection of future grid prices, that continued operation was economically unfeasible.

If you want competition to lower prices, you must accept that not all suppliers will be able to compete.

As for the cars returning from the eclipse, all were advised to have as full a fuel tank (or battery charge), as possible. I filled my gasoline tank at the outset for my 300 mile round trip, and came home with plenty to spare. At Newport Vermont, my viewing spot, gas stations were doing a great business as drivers topped their tanks for the trip home.
 
Similar things happen with gas stations during massive power outages. The one who has diesel backup generators gets massive lines especially slow filling gas cans.

There is enough charging with normal conditions however extraordinary ones not so much.
Absolutely. Maybe once or twice in my lifetime I had a problem getting gas. Sandy being the most recent, then decades ago when they had odd even fueling days for a little while, we managed. My bet is half the members on this board weren't even born then. EV charging problems seems to be pretty common this past winter for many EV owners. More so than me having problems getting gas in my lifetime. I'm pretty sure many members had similar experiences.
 
The State of Vermont did not "close its nuclear plant" Its owner, Entergy, did so as a business decision. The plant competed on the New England grid along with all other generation suppliers. The plant required a refueling, which would have been a $70 million commitment by the owner. The owner decided, based on its projection of future grid prices, that continued operation was economically unfeasible.

If you want competition to lower prices, you must accept that not all suppliers will be able to compete.

As for the cars returning from the eclipse, all were advised to have as full a fuel tank (or battery charge), as possible. I filled my gasoline tank at the outset for my 300 mile round trip, and came home with plenty to spare. At Newport Vermont, my viewing spot, gas stations were doing a great business as drivers topped their tanks for the trip home.
Wasn’t that simple. The Vermont legislature voted in 2010 against renewing the certificate to operate under political pressure from anti-nuclear protesters. Entergy won the court case against that action in 2012. But cheap natural gas generation, at that time, lowered electric prices and made the plant less competitive. They shut down in 2014.

Entergy was facing continued legislative battles, as the legislature was already considering further actions against the nuclear plant, which they could not afford in a time of low prices.

It wasn’t a simple business decision, it was a business decision forced by an adversarial legislative climate, in a time of reduced revenue.
 
The Vermont Legislature sticks its nose into a lot of things. But regulation of interstate power is by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, and the environment by the Federal EPA. The Vermont regulators could have a say on whether Vermont utilities should enter supply contracts with specific suppliers, but the economics of running a viable bulk supply are based on market clearing prices on the entire power pool.

My career was in the regulation of the utility industry.
 
The Vermont Legislature sticks its nose into a lot of things. But regulation of interstate power is by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, and the environment by the Federal EPA. The Vermont regulators could have a say on whether Vermont utilities should enter supply contracts with specific suppliers, but the economics of running a viable bulk supply are based on market clearing prices on the entire power pool.

My career was in the regulation of the utility industry.
I’m not disagreeing with you, I am simply saying that the cost of running the plant, and therefore, the business decision, included the cost of overcoming the adversarial legislative environment. The Vermont legislature had already tried to shut them down. The legal battle to stay open cost money. Further lawsuits, to overcome actions by the legislature, which were very likely, given the political climate, had to be added to the business decision.

The decision to shut down wasn’t the pure economics of the power market, it was partially the cost of fighting legal battles.
 
Absolutely. Maybe once or twice in my lifetime I had a problem getting gas. Sandy being the most recent, then decades ago when they had odd even fueling days for a little while, we managed. My bet is half the members on this board weren't even born then. EV charging problems seems to be pretty common this past winter for many EV owners. More so than me having problems getting gas in my lifetime. I'm pretty sure many members had similar experiences.
This is true. But there should be a way for good old capitalism to solve this. First, we need to let capitalism work and remove price gouging laws. If we allow the free-market to set prices, then it might be profitable for a business to break out a portable diesel generator and move it to these high demand areas and change what the market will bear. I'm pretty sure people will pay quadruple the going rate or more to charge their vehicle if it saves them a few hours waiting around. Even private individuals with level 2 charging could sell electricity to passerbys at a profit.
 
There was also spotty cell coverage since towers were engineered for a certain population. Is anyone in this thread going to go back to a copper landline because it might happen again?
 
People make incredible bad life decisions unable to think critically/analytically. Can't feel sorry for those who take along trip in an EV and get stuck. Lack of common sense teaches those with the same lack of common sense not to make the same mistake.
Oh... well, another life lesson for others to learn off their experiences.

Lesson #1
Dont take an EV to a major event if you are going to need to re-charge, take an ICE vehicle.
Lesson #2
Dont take an EV anyplace that you may get stuck in major traffic etc. during a storm or extreme weather, take an ICE vehicle.
Lesson #3
____________________________________ (example, dont trust that your teenager remembered to plug in the EV when he/she got home at 2AM and you need to get to work at 8AM) *LOL*
 
Last edited:
People make incredible bad life decisions unable to think critically/analytically. Can't feel sorry for those who take along trip in an EV and get stuck.
Oh... well, another life lesson for others to learn off their experiences.
But don't they have an APP to tell them where to go to charge, and the wait times? ;)
 
People make incredible bad life decisions unable to think critically/analytically. Can't feel sorry for those who take along trip in an EV and get stuck.
Oh... well, another life lesson for others to learn off their experiences.
So, what’s in our town a rare sight - a stunning model S - only she’s sitting at a stop sign surfing a dumb phone* - blocking others -
Well, money won’t buy brains - nor always improve attitudes …
*if needing a charge, 45 miles away …
 
Back
Top Bottom