This topic has been debated a few times in the past on this forum. Almost all of the arguments either way (including this present discussion) seem to be based upon "logic" with little factual evidence to back up the opinions, yet the writers are absolutely sure they are right.
Here are two quotes from the past, one for and one against:
Quote:
Yes. There is a lot of movement.
Some more than others, and an ABS system isn't certain.
At the shop we have performed and recommended turkey baster type flushes for people with economic restrictions. It usually helps or fixes some problems, and is certainly good maintainance.
My latest experience was a Chevy work truck. We had the owner suck out his master cyl and clean it, then refill with fresh fluid every couple of days. It would get black rapidly, then started to clear up, and his rear brakes started working properly again.
Of course bleeding the system is faster and better. But we have to deal with people with no money and broken off rusted bleeders.
I turkey baster my personal vehicles as a regular maintainance procedure
-quick and clean for PS and brakes.
Quote:
No it wouldn't. In fact I tested this by emptying out 3/4 of the resevoir of brake fluid and after about 500 miles of driving I could clearly see the line of new and old fluid in the resevoir.
I tend to lean toward believing the first quote is more representative of most vehicles. I also suctioned out a brake resevoir several times on an old vehicle and the fluid gradually went from dark to light.