Really?
I can't even get them off without tearing them.
Be extremely difficult to glue back on and have it look factory.
But, lets say this did happen, to 1 in 1 million jugs.
I'll take my chances on the 999,999 to 1 odds I get that jug.
Worst case scenario, drain the oil again, and redo it.
You probably had barely poured in any before you noticed it was used. Or before pouring any, stick your finger in it, and see if your finger comes out covered in dirty old oil.
I've done a lot of oil changes, know many more who service their own cars and trucks, never seen it, or heard of it from my friends, so it has to be rare.