Mobil 1 Advanced Clean formulation change

[tired]

but I suspect any Dexos Gen 3 oil that is GF7 is probably pretty good

So Supertech?

 

[tolian21]

my point was ...it is not the formulation, its the performance of the product that matters.

The performance change is also not quantifiable. We all know that they are looking for ways to make things cheaper, and have us believe that performance is the same or better. Cheaper/faster/better

 

[blue07silvy]

TRASH OIL. Used it for 6 oil change intervals of 3500 miles and it didn't do anything. I used Valvoline Restore and Protect for only 3 OCI's 3500 and you could see the difference using a bore scope. With Mobil 1 everything was still black in the cylinders.

 

[facility1]

TRASH OIL. Used it for 6 oil change intervals of 3500 miles and it didn't do anything. I used Valvoline Restore and Protect for only 3 OCI's 3500 and you could see the difference using a bore scope. With Mobil 1 everything was still black in the cylinders.

Be careful, there are a lot of Mobil 1 fan boys here, though it does seem a bit odd it did not do much of anything, Valvoline Restore and Protec may be a better product which it is.

 

[4wd]

Be careful, there are a lot of Mobil 1 fan boys here, though it does seem a bit odd it did not do much of anything, Valvoline Restore and Protect may be a better product which it is.

And you are the one who easily believes a post like his because you don’t like Mobil.

 

[facility1]

And you are the one who easily believes a post like his bcs you don’t like Mobil.

Just speaking a FACT. Mobil 1 is a fine oil, lighten up a bit .......ok

 

[Astro14]

Let’s knock off the bickering, and bashing, please.

 

[Astro14]

TRASH OIL. Used it for 6 oil change intervals of 3500 miles and it didn't do anything. I used Valvoline Restore and Protect for only 3 OCI's 3500 and you could see the difference using a bore scope. With Mobil 1 everything was still black in the cylinders.

I am struggling to understand your post - what was black?

If your piston tops were black - that’s not an oil problem. Are you saying that the cylinder walls were black? And that was the oil’s fault?

This is a 19 year old truck. Oil is the probably the least of its problems.

 

[tolian21]

TRASH OIL. Used it for 6 oil change intervals of 3500 miles and it didn't do anything. I used Valvoline Restore and Protect for only 3 OCI's 3500 and you could see the difference using a bore scope. With Mobil 1 everything was still black in the cylinders.

Oil was only around for 8 month, you are saying that you put 6x3500+3x3500 miles (31500) on your car in 8 month?

 

[kschachn]

I am struggling to understand your post - what was black?

If your piston tops were black - that’s not an oil problem. Are you saying that the cylinder walls were black? And that was the oil’s fault?

This is a 19 year old truck. Oil is the probably the least of its problems.

It’s completely unsubstantiated and who knows if it has any basis in reality. That’s the thing when people breeze in here with these extreme brand biases. Motor oil brands are just not that different.

 

[FDT09]

So Supertech?

I think Supertech has been independently tested and proven to be a pretty good oil.

I'm no expert, but I think at some point you're probably splitting hairs. Is Mobil 1 or Valvoline or Amsoil a better oil than Supertech? Probably. But over the course of 100,000 miles, is there going to be a huge difference in wear and performance? Probably not enough to have real world significance. I'm sure under lab conditions you could find a signficiant difference. Now R&P, does appear to have something to it. But otherwise, most of the other oils appear to have the same detergents, lubricity, longevity, etc., under normal change intervals.

 

[OVERKILL]

TRASH OIL. Used it for 6 oil change intervals of 3500 miles and it didn't do anything. I used Valvoline Restore and Protect for only 3 OCI's 3500 and you could see the difference using a bore scope. With Mobil 1 everything was still black in the cylinders.

What was "black" in the cylinders?

 

[kschachn]

What was "black" in the cylinders?

Probably didn’t have the light turned on.

Ya know.

 

[ChrisD46]

This is reading like an : “Oil Reality Show” !