There are different chemical makeups and properties of the various AT fluids.
My question is, has any had a negative effect on a transmission it is recommended for?
I have not seen any such studies...
I have used Maxlife in Hondas and Toyotas, as well as the Idemitsu fluids. Sometimes I even use factory fluids!
Our TSX with 211K is currently running Idemitsu Honda equivalent with a touch of Lubegaurd Red.
Dang thing runs like new.