Originally Posted By: Merkava_4
Try tapping on the side of the pan with a heavy soft mallet.
If that don't work, insert a stiff wide putty knife and twist.
Putty knife got it. Thanks for the tip.
Details revealed: it's the impreza in my signature. Factory fill at 52,000 miles (they say lifetime fluid... I say bite me, marketing team) so the orange gunk, which actually turned out to be pinkish, maybe from discoloration, was the factory "three bond" stuff. Refilling with Valvoline CVTF because they've updated their fluid to say it's specifically for metal chain CVTs, and it's available at o'reilly. It's amazing how burnt and weird the factory fill smells AND looks. I was shocked I only had a little bit of sludge on the magnet actually, I expected a heap of metal shavings.
I set the black oil-resistant gasket maker back around the rim of the pan after I cleaned the old gasket off (actually that turned out to be the most time consuming part... it was sped up a little bit by my MAF cleaner which dissolved the gasket slightly but not the powder coat on the pan). As per the gasket instructions, the pan is finger tight on all the bolts, then sometime tomorrow afternoon I'm going to go tighten it all up to the super light (5lb ft) spec and refill with the Valvoline CVTF.