I did something a little... strange

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jun 17, 2005
Messages
4,942
Location
Billings, MT
Yeah, I know there are a lot of people who won't approve of this, but I did it anyway since I like to experiment.

My dad is driving my old car, a 1993 Oldsmobile Cutlass Supreme SL with the 3.4 DOHC V6. It has had several oil leaks, and we've fixed as many of them as we could (oil cooler lines, etc) but there's still a leak somewhere. We think it might be the rear main seal. It has also had a lot of valvetrain rattle for the last 5 years or so.

Well, I saved the Auto RX clean phase oil that I drained out of my 1996 Crown Victoria. It is mostly Pennzoil 5w20 conventional, and it had 2502 miles on it, but about half of the oil had been replaced during that period. I added 1/2 quart of Trop Artic 10w30 that I had laying around the first time I needed top-off, and after that I used 2 quarts of Mobil Clean 5000 5W-20.

After losses from spillage and the oil filter, I had about 4 quarts left. I filtered it several times through some of the blue Scott shop towels. These seem to work very well as filters. The oil just dribbles through at a rate of maybe 4 drops per second. It took probably 4 hours to filter all of the oil. There was a bit of oil loss here since the paper towels soaked up some of it. You should have seen the sludge that the top towel collected, it was pretty nasty. I filtered it once more after that and the paper towel didn't look anything like the first one, it was dark but there was no visible sludge collected.

My dads car calls for 5w30, but we have been using 10w30 in it since we got it. I wanted him to run 5w30 in it this last oil change, but he had a stock of 10w30, so we used the last of his GTX API SL oil. It only had 300 miles on it, so I saved it and filtered it to use for the "rinse phase".

To make up the rest of the oil he needed, and to bring the 5W-20 up closer to a 5w30, I added the quart of Cenex Maxtron 5w30 synthetic to it, as well as a quart of Rotella T 5W-40 synthetic. I figure it is pretty close to what a 5w30 would be.

I put that mix in, and I didn't change the filter (Supertech) since it has so few miles on it. I'll probably change it in 1500 miles or so. He drove it home a couple days ago (about 45 miles). The car sat unused since then because he doesn't actually drive that much. When I called him today he told that when he started it up this morning to go to town there was virtually NO valvetrain noise at all! He was amazed that my crazy mix of oils could make that much difference.

That really pleases me, but now it leaves me wondering just what part of the franken-oil actually caused the improvement
crackmeup2.gif
 
New way to check the cleaning effects of additives. Filter through shop towels and see how much crud builds up. Sounds much better than the blotter test.

OTOH, maybe you filtered out all the VII and some of the additives, so it's now like an SA/SB 10 weight oil?
 
I would think that the additives would still be in the oil. The filtering didn't remove any of the darkness, so the dissolved minerals were likely unaffected.

If they were removed, I don't see how the engine would be running this smoothly.

Based on percentage of total volume that additives usually make up, there is no way I filtered them all out. There just wasn't that much actually left in the filters after I let them drain for several hours.
 
I figure I should give some background on this car before people tell me that I'm acting crazier than usual....

This was my car when I was about 17 years old, and I had it for about 3 years before buying a new one. I was driving it one night on a gravel road running parallel to the interstate. It was an unfamiliar road out to a house where I had never been. I was traveling a bit faster than I should have been, and the gravel was fairly loose. I thought I was supposed to continue on straight, because I could see the marker reflectors going on for miles. Well, the road suddenly turned left, and did not follow the markers. I tried to turn, but didn't quite make it. The car ended up in a ditch, on its side. The roof was mashed in, the front passenger door was crunched and its window shattered, the front fender was crumpled, and a fence post put a huge, long dent across my trunk lid.

They quoted me $5500 to fix the car, which was almost what it cost me. My dad and I decided to do what body work we could, straightening the door and roof out. We managed to get it fixed enough that they could put a new windshield in.

I drove the car for a few more years, but the problems were compounding. The suspension was somewhat messed up, there were oil leaks, the CV joints were making odd sounds... We decided that it was time I get a different cat. I wanted a Mustang, but used Mustangs were very expensive around here. I decided to find an old Caprice police car, but they're rare around here due to few departments using them. The ones I did find were pretty FUBAR. I was driving down the street one day and saw a nice looking Crown Victoria sitting in the K-Mart parking lot with a for sale sign on it and a price tag of $2750. When I pulled into the lot, the old couple who owned it had just shown up to show it to someone else. That person didn't seem terribly interested, so I asked if I could drive it. Long story short, I loved it and bought it for $2500.

That left me with an old beat up car that I couldn't do much with. I took it out to my dads farm, and it sat in a shed for about 4 years, unused, collecting dust.

My dad retired from farming in 2001, and sold off all of his equipment. He had a lot of spare time, so he did some upkeep around the place. He ran out of things to do, so he turned to my old car. We had been thinking about just junking the thing, but he decided to try his hand at fixing it up. We straightened out a bent control arm type thing on the rear suspension. He replaced the intake manifold gasket to try to stop an air leak that caused the engine to bounce off the rev limiter immediately after starting it. He fixed the leaky fuel injectors and replaced some vacuum hoses. A new fuel pump went in because the old one burned up before long. He finished the body work I had started, and repainted the roof and trunk. It looks much better than it did before.

He now drives it since it gets better fuel mileage than his pickup, and it is much more stable at freeway speeds. It's also very quick for what it is, and he gets a kick out of that on occasion. It isn't a car we're overly concerned about, so putting my franken-oil concoction in it, even if it would potentially damage the engine, didn't really concern us.

It's still early to tell, but I think it might help. If it keeps the rattle down, and slows or stops the oil usage, then I can see my dad driving this thing for years to come. If it dies, then my dad will buy that new HHR SS that he's had his eye on for a while.
 
Originally Posted By: chevrofreak
I would think that the additives would still be in the oil. The filtering didn't remove any of the darkness, so the dissolved minerals were likely unaffected.

If they were removed, I don't see how the engine would be running this smoothly.

Based on percentage of total volume that additives usually make up, there is no way I filtered them all out. There just wasn't that much actually left in the filters after I let them drain for several hours.
I guess you would need some extremely fine filtration to remove VII and additives, probably so fine you'd have to force the oil through.
 
I also did it in pretty cold temperatures, I started in the garage when it was about 40 degrees, then brought it inside for convenience. It was only about 65 in the room where I finished the process.

VII's should be pretty fluid at those temperatures, right?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom