Originally Posted By: Trav
Dot 5 does not allow moisture into the system it is not hygroscopic like glycol based fluids.
It is not recommended for ABS systems, HD used/uses it factory fill, I have used it in many bikes for 30 years with no issues whatsoever even in Honda's DCBS.
There are no real negative to using DOT 5 as long as the system has been thoroughly flushed and preferably dried. The positives of using it are it eliminates the possibility of corrosion when sitting long period like winter storage and reduced seal wear in the system.
There is no "new" DOT 5 non silicone only 5.1 which is glycol based.
Your point about using only spec fluid is correct but if done properly DOT 5 is a real alternative with added benefits. Did I mention if you spill it on you nice tank it wont damage or even discolor the paint, one of the main reasons HD uses this more expensive product,
http://etype.chrisvine.com/wp-content/uploads/documents/DOT5 Silicone Brake Fluid.pdf
Again, I would suggest people follow what the manufacturer requires. Its not brain science. Change fluid every two years and everyone will have a long lasting trouble free brake system and avoid any brake failure in extreme riding.
1. DOT 5 may not let moisture into the system BUT any moisture in the system will stay in there with DOT5
2. Like I said there is a NON silicone based DOT 5 and maybe I should have been specific but think everyone will agree its EASY for the consumer to confuse. The non silicone DOT 5 is called DOT 5.1
3. Bottom line, the automobile you drive everyday uses DOT 4, why over think it, for most people anyway.
If someone (like you and others) really understand what they are doing, sure whatever makes someone happy but again, its not an improvement as far as I am concerned, only a negative and why its not used in almost all automobiles but again ...

)
For the people who dont understand here is a GREAT short explaination - Click here
Here is part of it ...
"DOT 5 is silicone fluid and the above does not apply. Ideally, silicone fluid should be used only to fill non-ABS systems that have not been previously filled with glycol based fluid. Any system that has used glycol-based fluid will contain moisture; glycol fluid disperses the moisture throughout the system and contains corrosion inhibitors. Silicone fluid does not allow moisture to enter the system, but does not disperse any that is already there, either. A system filled from dry with silicone fluid does not require the fluid to be changed at intervals, only when the system has been disturbed for a component repair or renewal."
Also for the average person he/she may gets brakes serviced one day and if he/she switched the system over to DOT 5 (not 5.1) they may end up with a mix of DOT 4 and 5 since 4 is used in most all modern bikes and cars.
However I do understand what you are saying, honestly never really thought much about it until this thread, other then change your brake fluid on time, I learned the hard way when my rear brake stopped working on my then Yamaha vstar 1300 on a mountain road, 2 up and luggage. Vapor lock, caused the rear brake to fail coming down a mountain.
It was then, I found BURIED in the Yamaha Maintenance "NOTES" section not even on the maintenance chart to change brake fluid every two years.