HOLY PRICE JUMP BATMAN!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI

1 - on many vehicles the oil capacity is less than 5 qts so a 5qt jug is too much. Many people don't want to mess around with having to measure out 4-4.5 qts and then deal with the remaining .5-1qt.

2 - many vehicles take more than 5 qts. In that case you either buy the extra qt bottles you need or as with #1 you have to measure and deal with the extra left over.

3 - not every oil line and/or weight is offered or available in the 5qt jug so you then need to buy the qt bottles.

The 5qt jugs are a very good deal. Just not something that fits every car owner's needs nor is it something that you can always find in what you are looking for.



1) If you need 4.5 qts, what is the difference between buying a 5qt jug or 5 single qts? Still going to have .5 qt leftover. If you don't want to save it/use it for something else, just recycle it with your used oil.

2) If you are a DIY'er for oil changes, this should be factored into your decision to own the vehicle. If you take it to Jiffy-Lube, it is a moot point.

3) See above.


For most folks who drive average vehicles in average conditions, basic 5w20/5w30/10w30 will do, which is why it is the stuff that most stores carry. If your specific vehicle/instance means you need some exotic -30w/65 oil *sarcasm*, then one should understand that its going to be both harder to get and also more expensive. Don't get me wrong: I would love to have a Challenger/Mustang/Camaro and run a robust oil in it. I just don't see very many people buying singles in Wal-Mart whenever I am picking up some oil. Most of the singles are dusty.
 
I give up. I swear some people on here argue just to argue. Doesn't matter what the topic is or what you say some just have to take the opposite view just to do so.

21.gif
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI
Originally Posted By: Hokiefyd
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI
However, with all of that said, the next time you are at WalMart buying a 5qt jug look over at the individual qt bottles for the same oil and see what they cost.
wink.gif



They're not quite 50% of the PepBoys price you quoted, but they're close. PYB is something like $3.99/qt.


Around here the conventional oil in qt bottles at WalMart is within 25-30 cents p/bottle as it is the national and local parts stores. No $3.99 p/qt here.


I'm on the MA/NH border surrounded by 5 Walmarts including the one in Hudson NH. Stocked FULL of a wide variety of oil brands. My eyes see (on avg) 30% less than local auto parts stores. Prices have gone DOWN at Walmart in the past few months.

I disagree with your reasoning against the jug, and for the more expensive individual quarts. Here's why.

1) Cost. You wouldn't have posted this, because prices on the jugs have gone DOWN. All the good oils come in the jugs, so there are plenty of options.
2) Cleanup. Easy and far less of a mess mess to pour the old oil into a large jug vs holding a spout over each single quart, spilling and overflowing.
3) Fill. all you need is one spare quart bottle. Pour the extra 1/2- 1qt from the jug into the spare quart, save for top-off. Now you have the exact amount as one big pour! ahhhh! that was easy!
 
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI
I give up. I swear some people on here argue just to argue. Doesn't matter what the topic is or what you say some just have to take the opposite view just to do so.

21.gif



If I understand you correctly, your point is that even conventional oil has reached absurdly high everyday prices for one quart jugs.
I would be willing to bet that very little of this oil moves at those prices.
Thus, we see sales, oil change specials and MIRs.
The shelf price of oil means very little, just as the sticker price of a car means very little.
Nobody is really paying $6.59/qt for conventional oil.
There are too many less costly alternatives out there.
For those few who actually are letting themselves get hosed in this way, shame on them.
It would be cheaper to buy a 5qt or 5qt+ jug, use the four or four and a half quarts from it that you need and then throw the rest away.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom