Grease on a 1911?

Generally, oil for me. I also use a mix of both similar to what the 'School Of The American Rifle' guy posted on YouTube. I find it very good for AR-15 BCG.
Never had an issue using grease in a gun, but when it comes to 1911, I really respect Bill Wilson's opinion.
 
Even Bill Wilson’s “grease” is a thick, tacky oil.
Thus I will share with you the best "gun oil" I've used is SpectraSyn base oil at 100cSt. Thicker than many greases, never separates. This is the PERFECT lube for stainless slides like 1911s. It's pours about like honey as is almost as tacky. And it's impossibly slick.
I’ve gone back to oil on 1911s. Good oil, but the fact is - guns aren’t that picky. The act of lubrication is more important than the lubricant itself. I’ve tried G96, Hoppe’s, HPL, AMSOIL, and others - and the guns run correctly. If the gun is properly lubricated, and it isn’t running correctly - that is a gun problem, not a lube problem.
PUT THIS ON A PLAQUE. Of all the applications a lubricant faces, guns are among the easiest of all. Even some of the lowest grade lubes are sufficient for firearm use (witness the Fireclean debacle).

Now I happen to use a current mil-spec CLP that meets the stringent M249 test. But that's not because my particular application needs it.

The gun world is prone to many really dumb arguments, but none are dumber than arguing over gun lubes. Use lube. Wipe the excess. Live life. Literally dozens of lubricants can keep a firearm running quite happily a LONG time.
 
I have many high end 1911s and several big name gunsmiths I have spoken with always told me no grease just oil
Which makes sense because high end 1911s have very smooth surfaces. Remember, the roughness of the surface is directly related to how viscous a lube it needs. With a beautifully hand-polished Wilson, even sewing machine oil would keep it running nicely.

Greases separate in many instances. And the oil parts of those greases are often quite cheap. I made the mistake of lubing a bolt rifle with Lubriplate 105, which is a good grease for certain things. But it's an awful choice for guns. Made a mess and I had to clean, strip, and relube.
 
On a 1911 with a good slide to frame fit the slide will just plow the grease right off the frame the first time you cycle the action. There are 2 places that need grease. The plunger in the main spring housing and a dab on the hammer sear when changing those parts. EVERYTHING ELSE IS OIL ONLY
 
I have tried and bought lots of the fancy gun oils. I have settled in on Ballistol, which I have used for years and will continue to use, and Royal Purple 10W-40 dispensed from a pinpoint needle oiler. I believe that any commercial gun oil will do just fine on my firearms and that it is up to each individual as to what works best for them. I love this Forum.
 
I remember a person opined on anther forum grease shouldn't be on a 1911. Is that true?
Maybe grease is good for the summer but not the winter?
I thought about trying a thin coating of grease on the rails and locking lugs of my 1911.
The grease I have is Hoppe's.
I have the Hoppe's grease but I decided it was a little too thick.
I do grease my 1911 rails, barrel bushing, barrel and slide locking lugs but I use G96 RFG (Rapid Fire Grease).
Applied with a disposable glue brush that I've cut the bristles down to about ⅜" to stiffen them so it spreads the grease very thin.
This brush is kept standing in a plastic pill bottle that I punch a hold in the top. The pill bottle keeps the brush clean.
The rest of the pistol is oiled with G96 Gun Treatment CLP which I have in both the aerosol spray and liquid versions.
The aerosol is great for lubing the areas I can't access inside the frame. The liquid version allows me to put an oil drop right where I want it.
Like many of the above posters I've tried many gun oils and have also come to the opinion that any oil will do.
So I consolidated my gun cleaning and lubing products down to 1 oil/grease brand very few (G96, Hoppe's and M-Pro 7) solvents.
 
I have used sunthetic Super Lube with Syncon grease as well as their oil - I’ve even mixed the two together to form a thick oil and then placed in a gun grease syringe . Works great , it’s safe , no smell , fully synthetic , wide temp range , stays where you put it and long lasting .
 
I have always used grease and oil both.
Specifically TETRA gun grease, and M-PRO7 for oil.

TETRA is lithium based and goes on as a film, so its grease yet it does not attract debris excessively as one would expect from a higher viscosity. Anything that is stored for more than a month or 2 I apply grease, I also use it on EDC side arm.

I used to use grease for the long guns, and oil for hand guns. But over the years I have strayed from that due to how well the TETRA works. It was really hard to find several years back, but not now. I used to use old school cosmoline for really long term storage, I don't even do that now.
 
For most applications it's Coke vs Pepsi.

The bottle of Singer sewing machine oil I stole from my wife years ago works just fine for most everything. Regular lithium complex grease for everything else.
 
I have gotten into the habit of using grease on my auto pistol slides. It stays put better, and if you want to soften it up a bit, you can do so by putting a single drop of oil on it before reassembly.

I'm always more careful about this with Stainless Steel semi autos. This is because Stainless can be somewhat "gummy", because of the Nickel content of the metal.

Stainless Steel is far more prone to galling than carbon steel in similar applications. So I'll use a healthy amount of grease on my Stainless auto pistol slides. After a couple thousand rounds these surfaces will wear in, and the chance of having the slide gall up greatly diminishes.

Over the years I have seen this happen to several Stainless guns. And in most all cases, lack of lubrication was the culprit.
 
Frame rails, grease is fine. Not around the internals. I had a Kimber TLEII when they first came out. My first 1911 and read up about the 1911 being designed to be greased. I used grease for about a year and then attended a shooting and tactics SWAT class with other team members. About 3 hours in my trigger would not reset and the firing mechanism was "locked up". I was loaned an extra Glock 21 someone had and had to endure constant ribbing and teasing about my "John Browning Boat Anchor" until the end of the day. For lunch the next day, I shot up to a local gun shop that had a gunsmith who was retired from the Anniston Army Depot where he worked his entire adult life as a small arms repairman. 1911's, Springfields, M1's, M1 Carbines, M60's, 240's, Ma Deuces, etc.
The guy yelled for me to come around to the repair bench and asked "you use grease and gun scrubber or brake cleaner don't you?". I was like "yeah, how'd you know?'. He took his dental pick and fished around inside the frame near the lockwork and removed what I will call a "booger". It was a small chunk of hardened crap that had locked up the hammer/sear/disconnector etc. I said "what the hell is that?". He said never use grease and aerosol solvents. I used grease on the bottom of the slide that runs over the disconnector and it had shaved off grease. He said when I used aerosol solvent that the solvent didn't totally dissolve the grease/powder fouling that have gotten down into the lockwork. He said the repeated process of fresh grease, solvent, fresh grease, solvent, etc. had caused this nasty "pearl" of crap to be formed that got so big that it jammed the lockwork of the trigger! He said grease good on the outside rails but oil everywhere else.
 
I’ve been using Slip 2000 30 on this Cylinder & Slide Bespoke 1911 and it runs better than it did on Wilson gun grease

The 30 stays put butter in summer heat carrying this little gem and does not need as much maintenance

IMG_0730.webp
 
Frame rails, grease is fine. Not around the internals. I had a Kimber TLEII when they first came out. My first 1911 and read up about the 1911 being designed to be greased. I used grease for about a year and then attended a shooting and tactics SWAT class with other team members. About 3 hours in my trigger would not reset and the firing mechanism was "locked up". I was loaned an extra Glock 21 someone had and had to endure constant ribbing and teasing about my "John Browning Boat Anchor" until the end of the day. For lunch the next day, I shot up to a local gun shop that had a gunsmith who was retired from the Anniston Army Depot where he worked his entire adult life as a small arms repairman. 1911's, Springfields, M1's, M1 Carbines, M60's, 240's, Ma Deuces, etc.
The guy yelled for me to come around to the repair bench and asked "you use grease and gun scrubber or brake cleaner don't you?". I was like "yeah, how'd you know?'. He took his dental pick and fished around inside the frame near the lockwork and removed what I will call a "booger". It was a small chunk of hardened crap that had locked up the hammer/sear/disconnector etc. I said "what the hell is that?". He said never use grease and aerosol solvents. I used grease on the bottom of the slide that runs over the disconnector and it had shaved off grease. He said when I used aerosol solvent that the solvent didn't totally dissolve the grease/powder fouling that have gotten down into the lockwork. He said the repeated process of fresh grease, solvent, fresh grease, solvent, etc. had caused this nasty "pearl" of crap to be formed that got so big that it jammed the lockwork of the trigger! He said grease good on the outside rails but oil everywhere else.


I’ve got 2 bespoke custom 1911’s by 2 different world class 1911 smiths and they both said to not use grease on 1911’s unless you detailed striped and cleaned them even on the outside rails and to use a high quality oil
 
Back
Top Bottom