Free vs. Paid Anti-Virus Software

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Dec 5, 2010
Messages
1,098
Location
MO
Ive been using Avast (free version) for the past few years, never had any troubles with it. I have started to wonder about computer security lately however, especially with Tax season going on.

Any benefits of starting a paid service such as Norton or Kaspersky's?

Thanks!
 
i have pretty much the same questions.. I use norton here but have a free one at the office from microsoft i think security essentials..
I dont use the computers for anything like banking or any other thing that requires real security.. No real social security numbers or other information
 
Generally the paid anti-malware/anti-virus programs offer better protection (AV comparitives has shown this), though some would argue the incremental improvement is not worth $20-40/year.

I've stuck with ESET NOD32 for many years now. Not always the absolute best performer in the tests but it has been consistently near the top which means these guys have their act together and continue to work at it.
 
Usually had good luck with the free ones....but not so lately, and MSE really let me down.

For now, back to the paid ones....

Have to say (besides being annoying), Norton has done quite well....
 
Dave- Interesting point about MSE. A few years ago, my entire harddrive got demolished by a virus that MSE did not block and could not remove either.

Had to have it professionally restored and still I lost quite a bit of data. After that is when I got a backup external hard drive.
 
If you have a Windows 8 computer maybe try Windows Defender that is free and comes with Windows 8. I saw a test where Windows Defender did pretty good. Otherwise, Kaspersky is hard to beat.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: crazyoildude
how did they let you down i also find them not updating as fast as norton



MSE let a pretty big virus right through...after it had updated not even 10 minutes before. And I do not hit those spams sites either....
 
Kaspersky allowed viruses in that toasted 2 of my computers within 6 months. I deleted it and run MSE and check diligently with Malware Bytes now. Going on 18 months with zero problems on the free stuff.
 
My only experience with paid AV was McAfee 6 years ago. I put up with it for a while, but hated the interface and the way my computer operated with it and decided that the grief wasn't worth the cost. Had about 3 good years with free Avira, but they began making changes that I didn't like. Now I am running MSE (and Malwarebytes/Superantispyware) on two desktops for about 2 years now with no problems so far. I should also add that I pretty much stick to mainstream web sites and know enough not to download from untrusted sources or open attachments from unknown senders. If I do think a site might be untrustworthy, I use Linux for that.
 
I have used a couple of the paid programs and had no real trouble with them. Not long ago I started checking out the free AV programs. I tried Avast Internet Security's Version 7 free trial, it did OK as well, it had a lot of "neat" features to it but I soon found out I did not really need or use a lot of the features it had, so I downgraded to Avast Free version 7 and ran it for a while. I had no problems with either Avast other than version 7 Free seemed to slightly slow down my email and web browser. I got invited to try the Beta version of Avast 8 and I hated it. It slowed me down a lot and it had a lot of bugs that needed to be worked out. Avast version 8 really bogged down my email for some reason and I did not like that at all. It was a huge mistake for me to try the Beta version and I had trouble removing it from my computer.

I read up on MSE 4.0 and wanted to try it. MS has come a long way with MSE 4.0. When I finally was able to run the Avast uninstaller tool it took out some important Microsoft files from my system too. No matter how I tried I was unable to install MSE. I began to wonder if the MSE files were missing then what else was missing too? So I saved all my important files on a flash drive and used the HP recovery tool to reset my computer back to its original factory specs. I spent several days setting the computer up the way I wanted it. It really was not a bad thing to do, I got rid of a lot of programs and files I no longer needed.

I am now running MSE 4.0, have been using it for about 2 months with no problems at all. My computer is very fast and efficient again and I do like the fact that MSE is made by MS to integrate with my Windows 7 OS. I usually update it twice a day myself but I have found that its scheduled daily update works just fine by itself. I use the paid version of MWB Pro and have set up MSE and MWB with exclusions from each other and have had no problems at all with either one. I occasionally use the free version of SAS to get rid of unwanted cookies.

I have learned that keeping my operating system and all of my programs updated is critical to keeping malware off my computer. I use Secunia to monitor my system and alert me to any necessary updates. I also use Firefox version 19.0.2 with a few add-ons like Web Of Trust, Ad Block Plus, Web Mail Ad Blocker, Flagfox and Key Scrambler to help keep malware at bay and help keep me from clicking on a bad site or link. I have tried several AV programs and I believe you can get good protection from free programs. Using common sense when surfing online and staying away from known malware infested sites also goes a very long way towards keeping my system clean. I have learned that no AV program, whether paid or free will catch and/or remove all malware, but I like MSE and will stay with it. It is light and simple and works great, does its job very well without any problems.
 
I too have tried several anti-virus & anti-malware programs both free and those I paid for.

Have found that Comodo Internet Security is the one that I favor.

It offers wonderful sand boxing features.

Information about Comodo Internet Security

The free version has most of the features of the paid version. They made me an offer for a 3 computer One year license and I bought it.

Have it on 2 Windows 7 and One Windows 8 systems.
 
I have not used ANY AV software on my computer since about 2005. I follow other strategies to avoid viruses and malware. On my old computer, which was a PIII, AV software slowed it down way too much. I don't know what it might do on the new machine (AMD A8-3850), but those programs do tend to be resource hogs.
 
Originally Posted By: DBMaster
I have not used ANY AV software on my computer since about 2005. I follow other strategies to avoid viruses and malware. On my old computer, which was a PIII, AV software slowed it down way too much. I don't know what it might do on the new machine (AMD A8-3850), but those programs do tend to be resource hogs.



Not all. NOD32, for example, is extremely low-resource since it's written straight in machine code for efficiency.

Modern computers have more than enough horsepower to run AV programs, in my opinion.
 
^I am sure that must be true. My old system was a PIII 1.2GHz w/512Mb of RAM. Those were the motherboard maximums as I built the thing myself in 2002.
 
Originally Posted By: dparm
Originally Posted By: DBMaster
I have not used ANY AV software on my computer since about 2005. I follow other strategies to avoid viruses and malware. On my old computer, which was a PIII, AV software slowed it down way too much. I don't know what it might do on the new machine (AMD A8-3850), but those programs do tend to be resource hogs.



Not all. NOD32, for example, is extremely low-resource since it's written straight in machine code for efficiency.

Modern computers have more than enough horsepower to run AV programs, in my opinion.


This.

NOD32 is incredibly light-weight.
 
A nice setup for a Windows 8 computer would be to use the built in Windows Defender AV with the Windows firewall (hardware firewall in the router) and download the free Windows Defender Offline to use on a CD. Then you could get MWBAM, the free version, as a backup scan. And the Kaspersky Online Scan is free and could also be used as a backup. There would not be interference with the Windows Defender AV because those programs do not run in real time.

Otherwise maybe use Smart Security from ESET with the MWBAM and the free Kaspersky Online Scan.
 
Originally Posted By: DBMaster
I have not used ANY AV software on my computer since about 2005. I follow other strategies to avoid viruses and malware. On my old computer, which was a PIII, AV software slowed it down way too much. I don't know what it might do on the new machine (AMD A8-3850), but those programs do tend to be resource hogs.


I haven't run any antivirus program for years as well,no problems.
 
Mystic's post made me realize that even without dedicated AV software there are numerous defense processes already running on most systems. This is in addition to the Windows updates which almost always include a "Windows Malicious Software Removal" tool. You have the hardware firewall in your router. You most likely have Windows firewall running as well. These are not AV, per se, but malware takes many forms these days. The number of programs that include AV components are too numerous to mention, but I think you know what I mean.

I have noticed that you really have to be careful when installing anything from a download these days. There is a lot of good, reputable stuff out there that will install toolbars, change your browser's home page, or change your default search engine if you don't uncheck boxes while installing. I doubt that most of these are "malware," but just about any toolbar can be used as a data collection tool.
 
Agreed - but (for instance) the Malicious software removal tool requires you to run it manually - something the average computer user will not do. Most of them don't even know how. We're the 1%, it seems....

FWIW I haven't bought an anti-virus program since about '93. No one program catches them all, so I use four different free programs (AVG, MSE, Spybot, and MRT.) They are set to scan over-night on the weekend, so I can check the results in the morning. I don't have any of them set to continually scan, since I dislike the performance hit. I think the only one that's never found anything was the Malicious software removal tool - but I let it run anyway. Cover your butt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom