Originally Posted By: addyguy
You do have a nice truck, but as a general observation, I think these 'Ecoboost' engines will be a disappointment for fuel mileage as time goes on - Ford has really hyped them to do something I'm not sure they can do.
I tend to agree with that. Fuel mileage always seems much more dependent on the vehicle than on the particular engine, and an F-150 is an F-150 is an F-150. I'm sure the Ecoboost will do better than a v8 just because turbocharged engines are always a little more thermally efficient than N/A engines, but as for 21 mpg in combo driving? I'll wait to see. The Ram 1500 (310 HP 4.7) that I drive at times gets a solid 15 combo driving, and between 19 and 22 highway (depending on wind and how much the A/C has to run). Getting 17+ with an Ecoboost in combo driving is already a pretty significant gain over a v8, so I wouldn't expect another 4 mpg necessarily.
Actually where I'd really expect a turbo engine's gas mileage to shine is in towing, where the turbos are consistently working hard and the thermal efficiency gain is greater. IF a v8 gets 12 towing a load, an Ecoboost might get 15+ towing the same load. Of course that's also where I'd expect a small turbo engine to have shorter life than a bigger N/A engine, but I'm betting Ford got that part right and beefed the internals enough to take it.