Decided to Try a Carquest Premium.

Joined
Jul 8, 2012
Messages
5,660
Location
Dickson, TN.
So admittedly I’ve never paid as much attention to oil filters as I have, the oil itself.

When I started hanging around here about 15 years ago, I just looked around and most people said the Fram Ultra was very good, as was the M1. I remember Purolator Pure One was also thought of pretty well back when they were yellow. I even used these on my 2007 Yamaha R1 back in my sportbike riding days.

So I would always just use whatever everyone said was a pretty decent oil filter. And over the last few years, that was the Fram Ultra. It was easy to get, relatively inexpensive, and it was usually on the shelf at Walmart and I’d just grab one when I got my oil.

But recently I’ve seen some posts that they’ve cheapened them, and although the efficiency is still good (aren’t they still 99% at 20 micron), they no longer have the wire-backed fully synthetic media, and I think I read something about paper end caps.

So after reading some posts, I saw that a lot of y’all are liking the Premium Guard EX (aka Carquest Premium, Microgard sold through O’Reilly’s, and a couple more). I watched a video where a guy did a C&P on one and it looked beautiful inside with metal end cap, silicone ADBV, and an actual coil spring internal bypass valve.

Video:





I was in AAP getting some new spark plugs for the Tacoma today (heck of a deal on the OEM Denso plugs at <$5/ea there), and decided to pick one up for my next OCI on the Tacoma. It was about $10. A dollar more than the Fram Ultra at Walmart.

But from what I’m gathering from reading on here, maybe a bit better made than the FU?

I won’t be subjecting it to any very hard abuse, but it may be in service for as long as a year on the Taco, along with M1 0W-40 FS oil. Since I got the Elantra N, the Tacoma is not being driven as much anymore. Maybe 7-8000 miles per year. I last changed the oil/filter last June and I haven’t yet hit 7000 miles on the OCI.

IMG_6584.webp
 
So I would always just use whatever everyone said was a pretty decent oil filter. And over the last few years, that was the Fram Ultra. It was easy to get, relatively inexpensive, and it was usually on the shelf at Walmart and I’d just grab one when I got my oil.

But recently I’ve seen some posts that they’ve cheapened them, and although the efficiency is still good (aren’t they still 99% at 20 micron), they no longer have the wire-backed fully synthetic media, and I think I read something about paper end caps.
Fram Ultra don't have fiber end caps ... yet. 🙃 The Fram PH (and maybe the TG) might be going to metal end caps with an Ecore center tube ... seen those hit the shelves lately.
 
IMO, highest quality filter on the market at the member. I used Wix for many many years, and am transitioning completely over to CarQuest Premiums. BrendanC has a ton of C&Ps of Carquest Premium, every single one looks better than any WIX or Fram I’ve seen posted the last few months.
 
If you like one stop shop like me. My go to is Walmart. I was looking at the new Mobil 1. I like it Alot. After long decision lol. Between car quest and Mobil 1. I decided Mobil 1. AAP is a bit far.
If the Mobil1 transitions to all Premium Guard filters with the upgraded metal piece, probably will go completely Walmart and stop RockAuto orders for awhile.
 
If you like one stop shop like me. My go to is Walmart. I was looking at the new Mobil 1. I like it Alot. After long decision lol. Between car quest and Mobil 1. I decided Mobil 1. AAP is a bit far.
Yeah, I just happened to be in AAP getting spark plugs and had recently heard about these and decided to give it a try.

Otherwise I’m like you - I like to just cruise down to Walmart and grab whatever oil & filters.
 
If you like one stop shop like me. My go to is Walmart. I was looking at the new Mobil 1. I like it Alot. After long decision lol. Between car quest and Mobil 1. I decided Mobil 1. AAP is a bit far.

But you gotta be careful at WM.
A lot of stuff they have downsized...example....Stabil Marine 360 at WM is a 16oz bottle for the same price as 32oz bottle on Amazon and elsewhere. I'm seeing that trend more and more at both WalMart and HomeDepot.
 
If you like one stop shop like me. My go to is Walmart. I was looking at the new Mobil 1. I like it Alot. After long decision lol. Between car quest and Mobil 1. I decided Mobil 1. AAP is a bit far.
What specific revisions / upgrades come with the new Mobil 1 oil filter ?
 
This could be great news. The Achilles heel of the M1 filters to me has always been the filtering efficiency. It was a joke that the cheap Fram orange can would outpeform it. Even the Walmart Supertechs were as good or maybe even better, for about 80% less money. I always felt they were diminishing their brand a bit. That said, their construction (at least wth the cartridge filter) was robust, though.
 
Back
Top Bottom