I have no clue why, but I had the toughest debate with myself on which oil to use when I changed it out tonight. I first went for the Mobil 5000 5W-30 and the VWB 10W-30. After a bit of thought I put them back. I spent another 5 minutes pondering then grabbed the 5000 again along with a quart of Mobil Super Synthetic 10W-30 (my oldest bottles of Super Syn). I was happy with keeping the brands the same at least. I drained the old oil out. It wasn't terrible, and it's color was respectable, but it smelled ancient and had a bunch of floating junk in it that clearly didn't belong. At that point I got curious and poured out what was left of the mystery top-up oil. I discovered it was actually in a very old bottle (greenish yellow) of Poulan Bar & Chain Oil. I doubt that's what it was, it smelled like a cheap old motor oil to me. Anyway, when I poured it out, it was very thick. It poured like a 20W-50. I'm guessing it was some cheap XW-30 that got mixed in with some residual bar & chain oil. Once it was down to the last few drops, it was dripping out like the last few drops from a bottle of Lucas Oil Stabilizer. It was stringy! So glad I changed it now. Who knows what was actually in there...
Once it was time to refill, I called yet another audible. I put both types of Mobil back, thought about it for 10 more minutes and finally decided to pull the trigger on GTX 10W-30. I had 3 stray quarts, and decided to burn two of them out. After I poured almost two full quarts in, I realized I made the right call because I forgot it needs to be topped up now and then. So I have 1 last quart for top-up. I think it worked out perfect. Now I'll keep my eyes peeled for ND30 on the cheap. If I can find it, great. If not, I think I'll use Super Syn 10W-30 on the next one. I expect it will strain a little less on cold starts. We'll see. Thanks to all of you for your input.