I would choose depending mainly upon my desired drain-interval. If I was going to an extended drain interval, I'd choose Delo 400 because it has a much higher TBN, so it can run much longer. If I was going to stick with what I had already been doing OCI-wise, I'd stay with Supreme. There's no sense wasting the extra $1/qt nor wasting the fuel on a 15W40.
Supreme's moly (if it has any; I don't know) is a friction modifier and is there primarily as a fuel-economy improver, but it could also provide some anti-wear, IIRC.