Agreed, but would have breathed better, and so perhaps avoided the scorn poured on the 305. It's a trade-off for sure.
In general, for engines of the same displacement, oversquare (i.e. bore > stroke) results in slower piston speed, and thus greater ability to rev higher. The undersquare engine would have more low-end torque, but be limited in the upper RPM range, and generally turn in better (lower) fuel consumption.
It's hard to find real-life examples, as there are so many confounding variables - camshaft, compression ratio, carburetion, etc.
However, I would have loved to see the 305 tested vs. the 307 with all the variables controlled.
Mean Piston Speed (MPS)...I think that is what you are looking for. Long stroke engines have a faster MPS for a given RPM than a shorter stroke engine. MPS is limited to about 25-27 m/s (motorcycles and F1).
VERY generalized statement that would be fun to explore (all else being equal)
short stroke engines seem to be able to run higher compression ratio...would that increase CR offset a lower efficiency due to the shorter stroke?
I realize due to the MANY variables that dictate an engine performance it is hard to make blanket statements like "pushrod engines produce more torque" or "DOHC engines produce more HP and rev higher", but it seems short stroke engines tend to rev higher and be more HP focused, and long stroke engines do produce more torque and can be more efficient.
I know this is a big block thread, but I used to have a boat with a 5.0L small block (~200hp) with Vortec heads. Well...I was young, dumb, and well...yeah...dumb and failed to winterize it one year. Well the next summer I got a 4 bolt main 350, had it bored to 355 and prepped for marine use. Used the same heads and cam that were in the 5.0L...I did a ton of research and I want to say it was generally agreed if I stayed below 5000 rpm I would be good to go. That boat went from topping out at 51-53 to breaking 60 (all done with GPS). That had to put me in the neighborhood of low 300's hp, as I was running with similar sized bowriders with 350 mags (350 hp)
Last edited: