i have both the porter cable random orbital and the makita rotary. All I can say is, if you want awesome results and arent afraid to to practice on some neglected paints, then the rotary is definitely for you. If you want a polisher that will do better than by hand, or have a vehicle that is basically flawless, then go with the pc. Both these polishers have their pros and cons, but having both, you can decide which one youll need when say the pc isn't cutting it, its time to move up to the rotary. Also keep in mind that most of the heavy duty polishes like #83 meguiars dual action cleaner polish need to be broken down b4 removal, and a rotary is the best for doing that, but it can be done by a pc(just takes longer because it is not direct drive). As a fellow autopian, and many others on the board, Start with an orbital polisher first b4 you move up to the big tools. Always start with the least aggressive product first to get the job done.