Brake Failure

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 30, 2004
Messages
31,965
Location
CA
Earlier today, I noticed that my 96 Saturn SL2's brake pedal must travel to the floor before I have significant engagement.

This isn't the first time that I have had this problem. It had happened back in May 2009, but not with the same severeity. At that time, I just ignored the problem and it somehow went away on its own. I'm not sure what happened, but the pedal just firmed up one day and stayed that way until this morning.

Also, if I hold the brake pedal at a stop light, it does NOT drop. If I push and hold the pedal with the car off, it doesn't drop either. I pressure bled the system back in June 2008, so I don't think air is the problem. In fact, it would be odd for the pedal to be firm sometimes and soft at other times if I had air in the system, right?

So what should I do? I'm not sure how-to fix this. All of my brake pads appear to be wearing evenly. I do not see any brake fluid leaks.

Should I replace the master cylinder? If so, what brand? Raybestos or A1 Cardone? If I replace the master cylinder, how am I going to bleed the brake system? I do have ABS.

Thanks in advance!

P.S. Master Cylinder replacement is a big job on this car:

Quote:
REMOVAL & INSTALLATION
CAUTION
The ABS modulator pistons are normally in the HOME or top position. In this position, the modulator drive gears are under spring tension and will turn during disassembly if not unloaded. The sudden rotation of gears and release of tension could cause injury if done without extreme care. It is recommended that the pistons be run down and the tension released prior to removing the brake control assembly, if the unit is to be disassembled.

If removing the unit for disassembly, connect the Saturn Portable Diagnostic Tool (PDT), or an equivalent scan tool, and perform the RUN ABS MOTORS, PISTONS DOWN-REL test to run the modulator pistons down and release spring tension.
Remove the air cleaner/induction assembly.
Disconnect the negative battery cable, then remove the battery box and battery from the vehicle.
Tag and unplug the 2 electrical connectors from the solenoids and the connector from the brake fluid level sensor on the lower side of the fluid reservoir.
Remove the CPA device from the motor pack 6-way connector and disengage the connector from the bottom of the motor pack.
Position a cloth to catch any escaping fluid, then tag and disconnect the brake lines from the control assembly. Plug the openings to prevent excessive fluid contamination or loss.
WARNING
Once the brake lines are disconnected, do not excessively pull or bend the lines away from the module, or the lines may be damaged.


Remove the 2 brake control assembly-to-brake booster retaining nuts and remove the assembly.
If necessary, disassemble the unit as follows:
Remove the 6 gear cover Torx® screws from the bottom of the assembly and remove the cover. If the entire motor pack assembly is being replaced, skip to Step C, and then to the assembly procedure.
Mark the location of the modulator drive gears for reassembly. Insert a small suitable prybar between the holes in the gears to keep them from moving and remove the 3 gear-to-driveshaft retaining nuts. Remove the gears from the modulator.
WARNING
Do not allow the gears to turn while removing the driveshaft nuts, or the piston may hit the top of the modulator bore and damage the pistons.


Remove the motor pack-to-modulator Torx® screws and separate the motor pack from the modulator.
Remove the 2 modulator-to-master cylinder through-bolts and separate the master cylinder from the assembly.
Remove the 2 transfer tubes and O-rings from the master cylinder and modulator.
Remove the through-bolt O-rings from the master cylinder and modulator.
To install:

If necessary, assemble the ABS control unit as follows:
Lubricate the new transfer tube O-rings with clean brake fluid. Press the NEW tubes and O-rings into the modulator by hand until fully bottomed.
Lubricate the new through-bolt O-rings with clean fluid and install the rings into the master cylinder and modulator.
Install the master cylinder onto the modulator, and press the transfer tubes into position on the master cylinder.
Install the through-bolts and tighten to 146 inch lbs. (16.5 Nm).
Position the drive gears onto the driveshafts as noted earlier. Hold the gears from turning and tighten the retaining nuts to 75 inch lbs. (8.5 Nm).
Hold the modulator upside down with the gears facing you and carefully rotate each gear counterclockwise until movement stops. This will position the pistons close to the top or HOME position and simplify the bleeding procedure.
Position the motor pack to the modulator, aligning the gears, and install the 4 motor pack retaining screws. Tighten the screws to 40 inch lbs. (4.5 Nm).
Install the gear cover onto the modulator assembly with the 6 retaining screws, then tighten the screws to 20 inch lbs. (2.25 Nm).
Position the control assembly onto the brake booster studs, then install the retaining nuts and tighten to 20 ft. lbs. (27 Nm).
Position the brake lines into the control assembly as originally noted and tighten the fittings to 24 ft. lbs. (32 Nm).
NOTE: From the front of the master cylinder moving rearward, the lines are: LF, RR, LR and RF.


Install the 6-way wiring harness connector and insert the CPA device. Install the wiring harness connectors to the brake fluid level and 2 solenoid valve electrical connectors.
Install the battery and hold-down device. Connect the positive battery cable first, then the negative battery cable.
Install the air cleaner/induction assembly
 
Originally Posted By: moribundman
Have you checked the brake booster?


A brake booster failure make it more difficult to depress the brake pedal, right?
 
With a failing booster, the brake pedal may well fall an inch or two. Then you should feel a lot of resistance and very little brake power. What if it's a combination issue like a failing master cylinder and defective brake booster?

I'd certainly look for a vacuum leak around the brake booster.
 
With the car off, repeatedly press the brake pedal until there is no vacuum left.
Now wait a 1/2 minute and press the pedal.
It should be high and hard.
If your rear drum brakes have a lot of travel, rapid pumping now will show a medium hard pedal that raises to a high hard pedal.
All this is normal and good.
Let's start there.
 
Disable your ABS by disconnecting one of the wires and see if the problem goes away. On my 1994 Grand Am when I am braking over a bump and the ABS computer detects something, probably a broken wire sending speed to 0, the pedal collapses almost to the floor. ABS will not engage when standing still no matter what the failure which is why the brakes would work at a red light. I fixed it by disconnecting one of the wires to the ABS controller.

I'm as amazed as anyone that near brake failure is an acceptable failure mode of my ABS system for a wiring problem that is certain to happen.

The Grand Am did have low pedal because the self adjusters weren't. I've fixed the brakes but not the possibly broken wire so I hooked the ABS wire back up to see how the failure plays out again.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: mechtech2
With the car off, repeatedly press the brake pedal until there is no vacuum left.
Now wait a 1/2 minute and press the pedal.
It should be high and hard.
If your rear drum brakes have a lot of travel, rapid pumping now will show a medium hard pedal that raises to a high hard pedal.
All this is normal and good.
Let's start there.


Yesterday, I pumped the brake pedal about 20 times once the car was OFF. The pedal went down about 1/2 way and did not sink any further.

This car has 4-wheel disc brakes.

However, this morning, the brakes were FINE. No problems at all. The pedal was firm again. So now I'm puzzled. Do I have a seal inside the master cylinder that likes to leak intermittently?
 
Originally Posted By: The Critic
Do I have a seal inside the master cylinder that likes to leak intermittently?

The first time ('72 Maverick, no power brakes) I ever experienced a MC failure the pedal would sometimes drop to the floor during soft applications, but firm up when you pressed hard. Took it apart and put new seals in it. The old seals were worn. Good learning experience.

On my '85 SAAB 900, had a similar thing happen, so I got the rebuild kit. Found MC bore had corrosion pits right underneath the reservoir inlets that couldn't be honed out, so I had to buy a new MC. So now I change my brake fluid regularly!
 
A quick test for a master cylinder is to very slowly press the brake pedal [compared to a quick hard press].
If goes down further and further, it is leaking internally.
 
Originally Posted By: ron350
The Critic did you ever repair your brake problem.


As I mentioned in the original post, the problem is intermittent.

As of right now, the brake pedal feels perfect-- firm and the brakes work superb. So, with my laziness and the colder weather, I haven't dealt with it.

I did find a procedure for bleeding the ABS module without a scan tool, so I may try the procedure one of these days and see if that changes anything.

Also, I have been considering a complete brake system rebuild (calipers, rotors, pads, master cylinder) if I ever start driving the car a lot more.
 
Thanks for the reply my 96 Regal brakes have acted similar to yours.

Thanks for the info on the ABS VI bleeding at the Saturn forum.
 
If there is a vacuum leak affecting the brake booster, the engine would run poorly as a result of the leak.

Do you have intermittent engine driveabilty problems?
 
Artificialist thanks for the tip it is important that the vacuum booster does not have a vacuum leak.

I will check the manifold vacuum at idle and pull a vacuum on the booster and make sure it is not leaking.

I just discovered the vacuum booster on my 75 Chevy truck has an internal vacuum leak that I will have to fix this spring. A similar leak on my 96 Regal could cause all kinds of problems.

On my 96 Regal I lost ½ of the brake pedal when I replaced the front brakes for the first time. I made the mistake of opening the bleeder on the front calipers while I compressed the pistons to void the dirty fluid. No mater how much brake fluid I manually bled through the system I could not get a full pedal again.
I have since been told to never to open a bleeder valve on a GM ABS VI system unless a pressure bleeder is hooked up
 
Last edited:
I guess a pressure bleeder is fine.

One time I vacuum bled a 1999 Chevy Cavilier with ABS, and I had to completely bleed the ABS module+Master cylinder combo it had.
 
Mebbe apples and oranges, but to avoid messing with the ABS, I keep the MC reservoir fluid level above the ports when i have a line open. It is a bit messy , but the resulting gravity bleed gives ahard pedal with very little bleeding. TO the OP, I suspect that the MC is failing internally.
 
Yeah, I'd bet it's an ABS issue. When the ABS engages, it opens up an internal reservoir that "bleeds off" brake fluid and thus pressure from the system. I'd bet that it got some air in it somehow. On my GM, the abs module has bleeder ports on it; I have successfully bled them and gotten air bubbles out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top