nevering,
Quattro Pete was kind enough to post the link to by UOA above. I've used Mobil 1 0W30, Mobil 1 0W40, Amsoil 0W30, and now GC 0W30. The S4 just turned 134,000 miles and it still uses less than 1/2 qt between 5-8k OCI's. Honestly, the majority of those 134,000 miles were on Amsoil (I'd guess 80k of them), so your mechanic is full of BS saying that Amsoil is no good for your engine. I can say that I like the feel of the GC better than the Amsoil, maybe because it's sligtly thicker, but any of the above oils will perform well as refelected in my used oil analysis.
Congrats on choosing a great car. I hope to keep mine a while longer. Now stop worrying about the **** oil and go drive the car!