Audi A4 issues and problems?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Dec 4, 2004
Messages
2,183
Location
Lexington, KY
My daughter just bought a 2004 Audi A4 1.8T quattro with 24,000 miles from an Audi dealer. Seems like a rather nice car with auto sunroof, built in 6 cd stereo system. It was an Audi certified car with at least 3 years warrenty left on it. Anyone know of a good Audi forum or specific problems with this year A4? We sort of know of the 1.8 T sludge issues.

BTW, we went in to look at a 2004 BMW 325xi with 45,000 miles and to honest, the Audi just seemed to be a better car. TIA
__________________
 
Russell,

Nice car. The sludge issues are mostly from using non synthetic oil, too long or neglected OCI, malfunctioning pcv system, and the longitudinal engine orientation that limits the oil pan capacity to 4 qts oil. Also the 1.8t is pretty hard on oil. Be sure to stick with a 5K OCI, a VW 502.00 rated synthetic oil, and Audi OEM, Mann, or Mahle oil filters and you should be ok.

a_g
 
Quote:


We sort of know of the 1.8 T sludge issues.



Then you know how important it is to do oil changes, on time, with the proper oil. And to document EVERYTHING, because if she ever wants to sell it then a prospective buyer will want to see proof of how it was cared for. This does not mean every oil change has to be done at an Audi dealership -- it just means making sure all the maintenance is done properly and recorded.
 
Keep a very close eye on the PSF and ...too bad you can't use something thicker like M1 ATF or Valvoline Synpower PSF because of warranty. At least flush the system with Pentosin CHF 11S. Look into getting the coolant re-done with the new G-12 Plus rather than the Dexcool/G-12 used in 2004. You supposedly need oil w/ VW 502 rating, although one of the best new and not expensive oils out now, Mobil 1 5w-40 TDT would be great...no VW 502 rating. Mobil 1 0w-40 would be the best bet and also look into an oil extractor pump for easy oil changes inbetween dealer changes.
 
If it's an automatic, fluid needs be done about 50-60k, a $350 adventure. If it's a stick, I'd do the MTF at or before that mileage, not so much to keep the unit from failing, but for shift feel, smoothness and mpg. The MTF could be done for like $100 or less. I would not bother with the diff fluids until 100k.
 
Last edited:
Maintenance on the A4 was covered under the Audi Advantage Program. Intervals were 5k for the initial service, then every 10k (or annually) thereafter. I think the sludge scare was exposed in the early days of this car's life, thus it’s very likely that Castrol 5W40 was used since the first service.

The coilpacks seem to be another weakness in this vehicle. A set of the latest coilpacks run around $100 from ECSTuning. A failed coilpack may render the vehicle inoperable. Some people have made it a habit to keep a spare set of coilpacks in the trunk.

The timing belt tensioner, timing belt, and water pump MUST be replaced every 60k miles if you want this vehicle to last. The timing belt tensioner is infamous in this vehicle for early failure and will destroy the engine since the 1.8T is an interference design. The water pump also has a plastic impeller (may’ve been corrected in 04? ) and is also prone to failure. A timing belt kit from ECSTuning runs about $300 and includes an updated belt tensioner, water pump, rollers, timing belt, drive belts, and thermostat. There are excellent DIY guides on VWVortex that would allow any determined individual to tackle the job in about six hours. Otherwise, be prepared to shell out around $500 in labor plus parts at a shop.

4L of the Esso LT71141 fluid and a filter kit runs about $100 shipped from ECSTuning. Just measure the amount you drain out and replace with the same amount. DIY guides are also available online.
 
Hey, this is all good info. My daughter, of all my children is the most automotive prone. Even so, she does not do her own work, so I, the audi dealer and a BMW/audi independent will take care if mechanical side. She is good at detailing.. After all, she has seen how I take care of my BMW
smile.gif
 
The 5-link front suspension has non-replaceable bushings which require replacement of whole control arms- can get expensive.
 
Yeouch. Sounds as fun as a SAAB. I sure like Audi interiors.... I have two girls and while my wife thinks that when the come of driving age, a VW would be great for them, I am sure thinking Honda or Toyota.... I know how my wife was before we were married and I officially took over maintenance of her car. Women need idiot-proof cars in many cases. Not knocking them, just doesn't seem to be a priority...
 
I have a co-worker, single, 23 (smokin' hot), down here by herself from Chicago in a 2.0 Jetta she inherited from her granola-munching daddy. She's always taking it into the shop for one thing or another. The most serious was a clogged catalytic converter but it's always something. Just a few weeks ago she had to replace one of her tail-light harnesses or something. I've been trying to convince her to accept a free oil change but she thinks she can only use 10W40 from the VW dealer....

Oh well, that'll keep my wife happy.....

In contrast, my wife's CR-V is as maintenance free as possible. Changing out the dual-pump fluid in the transfer case and the auto tranny fluid has been the only chore in 5 years of ownership.
 
Just curious, wanting to become educated, as it were, why does it cost $350 to change the automatic transmission fluid on an Audi A4?

The more I read this forum, the more I'm convinced that I will never own a European car. I'd like to, but...
 
Quote:


why does it cost $350 to change the automatic transmission fluid on an Audi A4?



Because some dealers have learned they can get away with it?

Quote:


The more I read this forum, the more I'm convinced that I will never own a European car. I'd like to, but...



If you live in remote places like Idaho or North Dakota or Nunavut, it's more difficult to own anything but the least exotic vehicles on the planet. You drive what you can fix, or at least get fixed. Some folks need more of a support network than the UPS guy bringing boxes of parts.
 
Quote:


Quote:


The more I read this forum, the more I'm convinced that I will never own a European car. I'd like to, but...



If you live in remote places like Idaho or North Dakota or Nunavut, it's more difficult to own anything but the least exotic vehicles on the planet. You drive what you can fix, or at least get fixed. Some folks need more of a support network than the UPS guy bringing boxes of parts.




Yes, well, I do live in Idaho, and wouldn't trade it for the world. But in Car and Driver's latest 10-Best issue, I noted that it's not possible to purchase new (I think it was) 6 of the 10 "Best" in my town. And I live in the second-largest city in Idaho.
dunno.gif
patriot.gif


On the other hand, I don't go to the dealer for anything if I can avoid it, so maybe if I'm not afraid to get a little grease under my fingernails it wouldn't cost me $350 to change the auto trans fluid on one of these babies?
laugh.gif
 
Now you are catching on!!!!! Ya think I'd be able to take a SAAB 9-5 to a dealer every time something happens? Heck no! It's me, saabcentral forums, and a Haynes manual.....and a beer or two....
 
Quote:


I don't go to the dealer for anything if I can avoid it, so maybe if I'm not afraid to get a little grease under my fingernails it wouldn't cost me $350 to change the auto trans fluid on one of these babies?
laugh.gif





I've had my A4 for 11 years now. The dealer did more harm to this car than anyone with the slightest mechanical skills and common sense could possibly have done himself. Five years ago I began maintaining that car and repairing all the things the dealer let slide or missed (they misdiagnosed a simple vacuum leak as defective EGR valve, claimed the headgasket was leaking, while it was a $15 valve cover gasket etc), screwed up (I found at least a dozen things they broke (stripped screws, broken fasteners, loose connections etc). I wouldn't trust the dealer with something as simple as snapping the airbox lid fasteners shut. Once I lost the lower engine cover after picking up the car from service, because some genius forgot to put all the fasteners in.

If you can, do your own maintenance and at least small repairs yourself, because nobody else has invested more interest in upkeep than you.

All the proper fluids are available for half or less than at dealer prices. You just have to find a well-sorted auto supply shop or you can buy online.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom