Originally Posted By: BrocLuno
Short answer - NO ...
If they were, big rigs would be all over it. They count 1% fuel mileage as a huge increase. They are almost all sticks, unless working in stop and go or urban environments where they'd burn a clutch down in a week ...
Then please explain why so many automated transmissions of Volvo Class 8 truck sales in the U.S. Also by 2011, 80% of Volvo truck sales specs included their iShift automated transmission. In N. America in 2015, 83% of Volvo Class 8 trucks sold were spec'd with their automated transmission. The numbers aren't quite as significant for the other heavy truck OEM's, but automated transmissions from Allison, Eaton, Detroit, are really becoming a major percentage of class 8 truck specs. Many OTR fleets have moved over to automated transmissions almost completely. And it wasn't just because of new drivers that were not skilled with manuals. The carrier I do business with moved a lot of truck specs over to automated, and they do not hire new drivers, only experienced drivers and their standards are pretty high.
It really comes down to driving style. A good driver who understands the power curves of the engine they are operating can beat a auto in fuel economy. But the vast majority of folks have no clue about the relationship of HP, Torque, and fuel consumption mapping of their engine. For the majority, a auto will beat a manual any day of the week and twice on Sunday when it comes to fuel economy in a class 8 truck. And the spread is typically more than 1%. In actuality, fleets have seen 5% or better fuel economy of autos vs manuals. That is thousands of dollars per year per truck. Multiply that throughout the fleet. And given the majority of drivers, even drivetrain longevity is improved by using autos. Only the best drivers have an edge using a manual compared to an auto.
If I buy another Class 8 truck, it is likely to be spec'd with an auto. Not sure which one, Most of the bugs have been worked out of autos now, and I am just plain tired of shifting my truck. Almost 40 years shifting in class 8 trucks is long enough. Time to work smarter not harder.