As someone who runs conventional oils all his life in cold winter temps and has many 200k+ engines over the last 30 plus years in the family, I'd run XL with no worries.
Today's conventional oils are so good even in below zero temps so XL is fine. (heck, yesterdays did fine)
For a oil that is a 25k motor oil like ASL is, I'm not impressed with what I've seen. There have been a few UOAs that show it pretty well done *well* short of that number incl my own use.
The thing I like about XL is that Amsoil calls it a 7,500 mile oil and it does excellent in ALL of those 7,500 miles.
Take care, Bill