I received the Amsoil MTF on Monday and today I finally had the opportunity to drain the transmission.
First, the Civic drain plug isn't magnetic, which I found odd. Most are. So there was no blob of ferrous metals around the drain plug. Second, the factory fill MTF had been in there for 50K miles. Didn't look too bad coming out. Still honey colored.
Getting the new MTF into the fill was somewhat of a pain due to limited space.
So what's the result? Well, the Civic transmission is a slick unit to begin with, except for a slightly notchy 2nd gear in cold weather. It doesn't grind nor do you get ahead of the synchro it's just best described as "clunky". Today is perfect weather for that clunk. 24 degrees F. Initially I still experienced the clunk, but to a lesser degree. Probably just need to run it for a few days. But I did take it on a fast 20 minute drive on my favorite twisty. "Seat of the pants" seems to indicate even smoother shifting. And towards the end of the drive the 2nd gear clunk vanished. It did with the old MTF too once everything was heated up so it remains to be seen if it's gone for good. But overall, so far, I'm pleased.