In either case you're guessing without a way to measure.
My last interval was in the middle:
The WIX filter minder on my Toyota (in the sig) finally reached 11" after 6 years & 9 months. Gauge checked after a WOT run to 5000 rpm. Dirty side: Clean side: Close up: The new filter reached one click below 8" restriction.
bobistheoilguy.com