2024 Porsche Macan Review (loaner)

Joined
Dec 5, 2003
Messages
4,562
Location
New England, USA
We have a Macan loaner for a few weeks. I drove it across most of Massachusetts over the past few days and while I wouldn't be buying one on the near future, I will say that it is impressive and an excellent CUV. If you need some practicality of a larger, somewhat taller vehicle but want something that drives like a car, and a very capable car, this is it.

Fit and finish are typical Porsche and excellent as is the general design. I actually like the instrument panel layout better than what is in the current (and certainly the upcoming) 911's with their obstructed secondary gauges. Controls are well laid out and a decent combination of knobs, screen and touch controls, but more on that later. Seats are great and well supported but I can see them being a bit tight for someone large, but a tradeoff for the support.

Driving is excellent overall and actually somewhat amazing considering what the vehicle is. The ride is taut, not jarring, not even firm, but very controlled and I was impressed by the minimal body roll considering this is a CUV. Brakes are excellent. This thing is really fun and I will give it a great compliment by saying that it feels much smaller than it is, a combination of the driving dynamics as well as excellent visibility. The Macan wants to eat up miles at a quick pace.

The interior is a sea of black, nice black materials, nice black leather seats, nice shiny black surfaces, but black... Obviously, there are other options, but ours is black...did I mention how much black? Painful to keep clean and the black touch controls will always be displaying fingerprints. Easy to find a perfect driving position for everyone in the family who tried it so far.

I do have a few relatively minor gripes. The base Macan feels a touch underpowered and you have to really use a lot of pedal for quick acceleration. It certainly has sufficient power, more than enough, but any P'car should just come with more power and a perfectly progressive pedal. The a/c seemed a bit tepid when cooling off a hot car, not helped by the acres of flat black dashtop. However, there appears to be some customization of the fan speeds on auto, so this could be a case of driver unawareness. The last gripe is the touch controls on the console. Aside from the fingerprint issues noted, I'd be careful about resting my hand on the center console, but this could be Porsche's way of saying "Keep both hands on the wheel you schweinehund!":D

This is a really enjoyable vehicle if you don't need a full size SUV and pricing is comparable to similar Acura and Infinity models.
Macan1.webp

Macan2.webp

Macanspeed.webp
 
Last edited:
Was that the turbo 4 cylinder? I’m not sure exactly sold on a 4 banger in a luxury brand, but it looks like it is what it is.
Hi, yes. The power is there, but you really have to dip into the pedal. but the V6 would be more fun. Honestly, if you aren't a car junkie its fine and I could live with it. My Wife who is a bit of a car person loves this Macan.
 
Last edited:
I realize they are two very different vehicles and purposes, but how does the Macan compare to the Land Cruiser?
 
I realize they are two very different vehicles and purposes, but how does the Macan compare to the Land Cruiser?
Having driven them both for some distance back-to-back I'll sum it up by saying entrance ramps are a way to get on the highway in the LC and an opportunity for grins and giggles in the Porsche...

The Macan is really a GT car in the traditional European sense; a well driving, handling and stopping, comfortable but not too cushy vehicle capable of long-distance cruising at high speeds, it just happens to be a bit tall with four doors and a hatchback. Think of a 928 that you can put car seats or adults in the rear seats and groceries in the back.

The LC is an SUV, that seems focused on the 'U'. It is a bit truck like in ride and handling, but not overly so. I'll describe the overall feeling as 'capable' if that makes sense; it is ready for work.....whatever that reasonably means to you. It rides like the Defender and noticeably harsher than my Range Rover, but not objectionably so. I need to drive my friend's Tundra again, but I'd expect the overall feel to be similar.

I did find the LC's ride to be excessively jiggly, much more so than I thought I remembered from the test drive. Then as I was setting the car up and running through the systems, I noticed the tires were at 55 psi cold. They should be 33.
 
I’ve looked at these curiously as a potential second owner, second car. Rear main seal and other rubber parts have had me wary. I sat in one not too long ago and the quality, airiness and ergo of the cockpit was true European, and I found it a better fit for me than Volvo or bmw. I’m a bit nervous that they might be a little needier than either of those brands, however. The dash from the drivers seat is superb.
 
I’ve looked at these curiously as a potential second owner, second car. Rear main seal and other rubber parts have had me wary. I sat in one not too long ago and the quality, airiness and ergo of the cockpit was true European, and I found it a better fit for me than Volvo or bmw. I’m a bit nervous that they might be a little needier than either of those brands, however. The dash from the drivers seat is superb.
I wouldn't worry excessively about either of those problems, as I don't expect Porsche to be materially worse than the other Euros. That being said, we have this loaner because the new 911t has a transaxle leak at ~1,800mi, necessitating removal of the transaxle...:oops: Per the Dealer "Porsche is very interested in this".
 
Last edited:
We have a 4 cylinder in our Audi Q5 and I have no complaints about 250 hp and smooth as silk. and not bad on gas either.

View attachment 247640


The EA888 Gen3 and Gen4 engines have a ton of usable power.

Our 24’ VW Atlas has the Gen4 EA888 rated at 269HP and I never feel like the vehicle is lacking In power even as a 3 Row family hauler. It feels especially strong on the Highway at higher speeds (85-100mph).
 
Back
Top Bottom