Interesting post,
We also live in northern Michigan, are coming from a German sedan (Audi A6). My wife has always had back issues and can tell within a minute of sitting in a vehicle. The seats were comfortable in the Audi, handling and performance was great, but the cost to maintain and repair wears on you... a burnt out LED taillight was $2000 - $5000 to fix. Can’t make this $hit up.
So last February, before heading to Florida we looked at vehicles...my wife has always had a bad back and car rides are particularly bad so needed seat comfort was very important, along with AWD as we live in NE Michigan snow belt, and ride comfort. Found that “standard” makes did not offer fully adjustable passenger seats. So for example a $50,000 Toyota Highlander did not have fully adjustable passenger seats, the Kia Telluride did at the highest trim level...but was also $50,000 with rumors of bidding wars. Premium vehicles do offer full seat adjustments on both driver and passenger seats, but also at higher trim levels. Did not want to do the German thing again, did considered Volvo but also a European make.
We were down to the Acura RDX and the Lexus RX 350...there are no dealerships up here in northern Michigan so had to go 300+ miles downstate to drive these and actually had money down on a Lexus. After driving the two it was hands down on the Acura...the seat comfort was awesome, felt the Lexus 8-speed tranny was indecisive and the Acura 10-speed was spot on, the Acura SH-AWD was a pleasant surprise...always considered Audi and Subaru to be the top AWD systems out there but the SH-AWD had great reviews. Need to get the Advanced trim level in order to to get fully adjustable driver and passenger seats along with the “better” ride package. Would have preferred the Lexus 6 cylinder over the 2.0T…but?
My understanding is that the excessive Honda fuel dilution issue was with the 1.5T...although folks don’t seem to be too concerned about it on the CR-V forums?
All I can say is that my wife loves this vehicle so far…
Oh should you decide RDX, we drove to Chicago…the sticker on an Advance is $49,500. We got it for $42,000, no dickering…he gave the price right away on the phone. Michigan dealers were $2500 higher. Now the Lexus we looked at…the price in Ann Arbor was just slightly more than Chicago.