Do you realize all you've been doing is posting irrelevant points.Ask just about anyone here what their opinion is on WS fluid. You really can't win this one but I believe from having read some of your posts you're not the type to let it go, it's just not in you.
Saying "I'm of the BITOG forums" does not establish your own credentials nor does it establish the credentials of all the other individuals on this board as some sort of expert.
Two, it does negate the experiences of people who resolved the symptoms in their transmission by going back to WS.
The other fallacy is presenting your own experience switching to Amsoil, which is a different product from Valvoline Maxlife.