2002 Camaro SS, Royal Purple 10w30

Status
Not open for further replies.
quote:

I walked through the Paddock at Limerock Park on Memorial day and looked at all the racers in the Speed Touring, Speed GT and SCCA Trans-Am classes and 95+% of them (with nearly 100 cars total) used Red Line Oil. Two used Royal Purple and I think I saw a Valvoline patch on one of the driver's nomex racing suit ... but it might have been old.

Just corious, just how many did YOU actually see with redline oils sitting in the pit and not just a sticker on something, cause as you well or should know, there is a lot that flash stickers and patches if someone pays for it. Be honest now.

And BTW, Schaeffers racing oil, same deal, Very Low detergents and made for racing as oppose to street.

You gotta remember, The main difference here is you're submitting to it being a full synth as I am with a blend, both have the High Levels of additives to resist wear, so the main difference here is extreme cold pumpablilty like that is an issue for race cars, and extended long duration of oil drains. My point is, Redline has no true benifet over Schaeffers when it comes to racing oils IMO, except making your wallet lighter.
 
Speaking of race oils, is there really a need for them to be a fully synthetic base oil, when they are not in there for very long anyways?
 
Bobis: " ... did YOU actually see with Red Line oils sitting in the pit and not just a sticker on something, cause as you well or should know, there is a lot that flash stickers and patches if someone pays for it."

That's a good point, Bob and one I make all the time when I see corporate sponsorship on race cars ... especially with a product like oil where some teams claim they use the same oil in their race car which is available on store shelves. Most of the time it’s B.S. and their spokespeople are careful to work in some nonsense wiggle-words into any comment made about the oil companies. Ron Dennis of MacLaren has a lot of nice things to say about the Mobil corporation but doesn’t say he uses their oils straight out of the bottle in their Formula 1 cars. Likewise, Unocal 76, the official oil of NASCAR, says they “make these available” to the various NASCAR teams but you know that most teams use something else ... or at the very least they have a MAJOR sponsorship conflict.

The truth of the matter is yes, in many of the trailers and temporary garage areas at Limerock you could see the actual bottles of Red Line oil sitting there on the benches, shelves, in chests, etc ...

I suppose those teams could have gotten some empty Red Line bottles and put something else in them ... but that (to me) is stretching it. That sounds a little close to a conspiracy theory and I don't believe in too many of those. Likewise, I don't find myself searching the sky for black helicopters, etc ...
wink.gif


But, even before my trip to Limerock, I have always believed that the guys who SAY they use Red Line in their race cars (by the stickers on their vehicles) actually use it is a matter of business and simple economics.

Let's say that what Red Line does is pay a lot of these small time (semi-pro) racers to show their logo (in locations on the car of varying prominence) on their race cars but those racers actually use some other kind of oil.

That’s possible, but then what’s the point of the sponsorship? sure, most of the big oil companies advertise this way and then they expect the motoring masses to pick THEIR oil when shopping at Wal-Mart or auto parts stores or request it when visiting their neighborhood garage. The profit from these sales covers the cost of the racing sponsorships. Red Line doesn’t do this. You can only get Red Line through specialty outlets that cater to racers and serious hot-rodders. In this area, I’m the only guy I know who runs Red Line in an automobile locally. Where are they getting the money to pay for racing? The obvious answer is that this business model can’t work. Actual racers make up a large portion, possibly most of Red Line’s paying customers.

See what I’m saying? Taking a loss by sponsoring racers in order to appeal the consumer and industrial market doesn’t work because most of that market has never heard of Red Line and would balk at paying $6-8 for a quart of oil anyway. Racers ARE Red Line’s market. If the racers advertising Red Line actually used some other kind of oil, Red Line would have gone out of business a decade or more ago. Tell me if you see a flaw in that logic because I can’t see any other way for them to stay afloat.

As for sponsorships, Red Line probably offers some money to teams showing their logo who finish in the top positions in a given racing class/types/series with the amounts varying depending on how high-profile that race series is. But, I doubt this amounts to much. Johnny might know more about these sponsorship deals and what they typically involve.

“Schaeffer’s racing oil, same deal: Very Low detergents and made for racing as oppose to street. You gotta remember, The main difference here is you're submitting to it being a full synth as I am with a blend, both have the high Levels of additives to resist wear, so the main difference here is extreme cold pumpability (like that is an issue for race cars) and extended long duration of oil drains. My point is, Red Line has no true benefit over Schaeffer when it comes to racing oils IMO, except making your wallet lighter.”

I’m not sure if that’s the whole story. Won’t Red Line’s synthetic base pump easier at operating temp? That is one of their selling points. Use a thinner, full-synthetic oil (at least thinner than older straight weights) and gain more horsepower through reduced pumping losses.

They also advertise the benefits of the high temp protection of polyol versus mineral and PAO-based stocks which will shear down and thin out at higher temps sometimes found in racing conditions. This is essentially what Patman asked. My answer to him is it depends on what kind of oil temps you are running. If you run a more aerodynamic shape (fewer air inlets) and/or run a smaller radiator with reduced capacity (less weight), that is an advantage in a race ... but you’ll want to have an oil that will still perform well at temps which might run an additional 20-50F or more hotter.

Like I said above, this kind of performance is probably overkill ... even for most racers ... but if you’re turning some serious RPMs and/or are running an endurance race, the extra $$$ spent on the best lubricant is peanuts.

Johhny, how many people still use the straight weights for racing? I look at that approach as really dated in most applications. If I had a Formula Ford or an Acura Integra (high winding 4-cyl), I couldn’t imagine putting that thick goo in my ride. Too much power lost pumping that stuff through the motor. I remember seeing the on-line MSDS sheets for that “Pennzoil GT” formula but I don’t think I’ve ever actually seen a bottle up close. I still occasionally see the Valvoline straight racing weights and years ago I used to see the Castrol straight racing grades ... but both of these have been fading from the shelves, at least around here.

Wouldn’t you love to be a part of a special Pennzoil team producing modern, custom-blended Group IV and Group V racing lubes for a handful of high-profile racing teams? It might require a bit of travel to racing tracks all over the country, possibly the globe ... think you could handle that?
grin.gif
 
Bror Jace: You start a flame war, well I just can't believe it.
grin.gif


We do make a very good racing oil, but I would not recommend it in engines that are turning extremely high RPM'S. What we do make works extremely well is drag racing and sprint car racing applications. It is our GT Racing Oil and it comes in 3 weights. 25W50, 50, and 60. It is not for street use. Very low in detergents.
cheers.gif
 
Bror Jace: Back in the early days of my employement with this company, I did just that. I was at most of the NHRA races and about 25% of the CART races. That was back in the good old days when Rick Mears ran the Pennzoil car for Penske. As for as the heavy straight weight oils, mainly some of the top fuel cars still use these. Before Eddie Hill retired, he was using our GT Performance 25W50 in his car. The 25W50 is one of the favorites in the World of Outlaws series, but some of them are starting to use the Red Line product. I do know a little about Red Line sponsorships. About 95% of the racers using Red Line actually pay for it. The other 5% have it furnished to them free, but they do not receive any money from Red Line, unless there might be some contingency monies at some of the events.

Oh, we do make special synthetic racing oil. REAL SYNTHETIC (PAO, ESTER, ETC.). The problem is, you can't buy it. But you can be sure on race day, anyone in NASCAR, or IRL that is associated with us (and that is more than you think), is not using another product. On the Union 76 topic, not as much of their oil being used as it use to, but all the gas is Union 76.

You are correct in your statement about the marketing aspect of this. Pennzoil, Quaker State, Mobil, Valvoline, Castrol, and now Chevron/Havoline, spend a fortune on racing just to sell that extra quart on the shelf. It is your three favorite words, MARKETING, MARKETING, MARKETING.
cheers.gif
 
Was this the first change to RP? I haven't seen it mentioned already, so I'll ask. Is is fair to judge an oil based on it's first oil change? I would think that you would need to run the same brand oil a couple of times to get a true analysis of that oil.
 
It was his first change to RP, and you do raise a good point. As Trevor mentioned, he's going to do another 1200 mile interval and analyze it yet again.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Bror Jace:

I suppose those teams could have gotten some empty Red Line bottles and put something else in them ...


That reminds me... when I was watching (a small fraction of) Le Mans, I saw one of the pit crews pouring oil from a container that looked just like my 5-quart Mobil 1 jugs. I could only see the back, but it was the same grey, angular looking jug they sell at Wal-Mart. I figured that it must be the same stuff, because if Mobil was smart enough to supply Top Seekrit Race Oil in consumer-style bottles, they'd also be smart enough to make the pit crews point the label at the camera!
cool.gif
 
Johnny: “Back in the early days of my employment with this company, I did just that. I was at most of the NHRA races and about 25% of the CART races…”

Sounds neat … and yes I remember those guys. I wrote my previous post off-line and I didn’t remember that you stipulated that it was mostly circle track guys that still used the straight weights … but as you stated, it’s just a matter of time before those guys see the light and use an oil that doesn’t work against them so much.

“About 95% of the racers using Red Line actually pay for it. The other 5% have it furnished to them free, but they do not receive any money from Red Line, unless there might be some contingency monies at some of the events.”

That’s about what I figured. I figured they DO pay some money because a Toyota Atlantic (previously Formula Atlantic) racer implied he got money from them. But, keep in mind that Toyota Atlantic is just one step below CART, i.e., BIG TIME!! I can’t believe the typical SCCA racer running GT-4, GT-5, Formula Mazda or Sports Type-D cars get much if any money.

“Oh, we do make special synthetic racing oil. REAL SYNTHETIC (PAO, ESTER, ETC.). The problem is, you can't buy it. But you can be sure on race day, anyone in NASCAR, or IRL that is associated with us (and that is more than you think), is not using another product.”

Don’t you wish they’d put this stuff in racing bottles and make it available in specialty outlets? I know the finance guys say it isn’ t worth it ... but I’d like to see the stuff being sold. I guess they want people to think that the stuff on the shelves is the same in the race cars … and that strikes me as dishonest. Mobil 1 is the main offender in this category. I know some teams who race use this stuff ... but I know I wouldn’t!
rolleyes.gif


If you read on the back of the bottle, it says Mobil 1 SuperSyn is for “amateur racers.” Well, I know if I were racing, I’d take myself a little more seriously than that!

“You are correct in your statement about the marketing aspect of this … it is your three favorite words, MARKETING, MARKETING, MARKETING.”

grin.gif


mph, seriously? I think that those containers were just the most convenient containers they had available when they went to bottle their custom formulated concoction. I don’t begrudge Mobil whipping up special batches of oil for F1 or Group C cars, I just think they are at least a little sleazy for implying that it is the same formula one can buy for their street ride.
rolleyes.gif
 
quote:

Originally posted by Chris A:
Was this the first change to RP? I haven't seen it mentioned already, so I'll ask. Is is fair to judge an oil based on it's first oil change? I would think that you would need to run the same brand oil a couple of times to get a true analysis of that oil.

Actually this was NOT the first time to use Royal Purple. I changed over to RP at 5,000 miles from Castrol dino 10w-30, and I've only used RP since then. This is just the first time that I've had it analyzed.
 
I'd like to bring this one back up again to discuss it some more. I mentioned earlier that I thought the oxidation was pretty high for an oil with such low miles. At 29% with only 1250 on the oil, that sounds really quite extreme. What could cause this to happen? If it's at 29% already at just over 1000 miles, I'd hate to see it after 3k!
 
The oil sample results above inadvertantly left out Phosphorus=840 ppm .

As far as Racers oil patches on suits etc. I know that most would wear any patch as long as the sponsor was feeding us $$$$ to them. For instance Redline has a long history of giving out race suits to Pro Road Racers. I was sponsored by Synergyn and wore their colors on my suit. I also used their products. As far as what oil is being used can depend on alot of things,brand being the least unless the sponsor catches you using a competitors oil
nono.gif
.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom