'03 BMW 330Ci M54, German Castrol, 2674 miles

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 3, 2011
Messages
4,426
Location
The Willow Creek District AVA
Hello Folks:

My special ordered (no sunroof), bought new 2003 BMW 330Ci ZSP with 5-speed manual. 3,000 mile OCIs since new, Hengst oil and air filters. FF and oil filter changed at 500 miles, then again at 1,000, then again at 1,750, then again at 3,000. At 3,000 miles the regular 3K OCIs began. I mention this because of all the controversy regarding early drain of FF. In my case, it obviously caused no harm whatsoever. I drain FF early on ALL my cars.

The car is one of four cars and with me having been either working from a home office or retired, the car is not driven regularly. It's kind of a garage queen, actually. It's never once been driven in the rain or on wet roads, and has never been parked outside overnight. It sits covered in the garage for periods as long as two weeks before I feel I must take it out and get it warmed up and "wet". The short 3K OCIs are for time periods of approximately 9 months.

I used Mobil 1 0W-40 for the first 40K miles, then German Castrol since then. Occasionally, I've experimented with a few other oils, like the Motul 300V 5W-30 shown in the previous sample.

Scott


Code:
Oil German Castrol Motul 300V 5W-30 Universal Averages

Miles in Use 2,674 2,655 Based on 6,400

Miles 78,011 68,125

Sample Taken 30Nov13 24Feb11



Aluminum 2 1 4

Chromium 0 0 0

Iron 6 7 15

Copper 7 4 10

Lead 1 4 5

Tin 0 0 1

Moly 2 734 107

Nickel 1 1 1

Manganese 0 1 2

Silver 0 0 0

Titanium 0 0 0

Potassium 6 0 3

Boron 2 18 54

Silicon 2 9 5

Sodium 3 7 15

Calcium 1896 1677 2320

Magnesium 536 981 169

Phosphorus 899 1105 845

Zinc 1014 1199 1002

Barium 0 0 0



SUS Visc @ 210*F 63.2 67.8 59-68

cST Visc @ 100*C 11.11 12.37 9.9-12.7

Flashpoint (*F) 415 430 >365

Fuel (%)
Antifreeze (%) 0.0 0.0 0.0

Water (%) 0.0 0.0 0.0

Insolubles (%) TR 0.3
TBN 9.2 7.8 >1.0


Blackstone comments (2674 mile sample, most recent one):

The second report from your E46 looks just as good as last time. Were metals are all reading within a few parts per million of the previous values, and that means there have been no significant changes over the last 10,000 miles - a great indication that this engine is running smoothly and that no mechanical problems are developing. We didn't find any harmful contaminants or other physical problems in the oil, and the TBN is still very strong at 9.2, so this Castrol has plenty of active additive remaining. You've got a good thing going with this engine.

Blackstone comments (2655 mile sample):

This first sample from the 3.0L in your BMW looks really good. Universal averages show typical wear levels for this type of engine after about 6,400 miles on the oil. This oil wasn't in place nearly that long, which explains the lower wear. From what we can see, this M54 is doing just fine mechanically. The viscosity was normal for a 5W-30 and no fuel dilution or coolant contamination was found. Low insolubles and silicon show good oil and air filtration. The TBN was strong at 7.8 showing plenty of active additive, less than 1.0 is too low. Nice engine.
 
I see no reason to drain the oil so soon. Report looks good because you're barely driving it! Go enjoy that thing.
 
Looks good. I would not be surprised if Calif. would enact a law that you must run the oil 5000 miles. Its the kind of thing Calif. would do.

I would ignore universal averages from Blackstone. And their comments.
 
Originally Posted By: Donald
I would not be surprised if Calif. would enact a law that you must run the oil 5000 miles. Its the kind of thing Calif. would do.

Yeah, like NY banning the sale of large soft drinks!
 
Originally Posted By: dparm
I see no reason to drain the oil so soon. Report looks good because you're barely driving it! Go enjoy that thing.

Agree on all counts, but because it's driven so rarely there are times I feel compelled to do something to it. Know what I'm saying? Heck, it's driven so rarely that every time I wash it I end up putting on a quick coat of polymer sealant as well! My fleet of fully custom, high-end road bicycles seem to be taking all my time now. There are many things about retirement that are good, except for the realization that one is aging. Haha!

Scott
 
Originally Posted By: SLO_Town
I mention this because of all the controversy regarding early drain of FF. In my case, it obviously caused no harm whatsoever.

It doesn't cause harm. The question is: does it help in any meaningful way, other than letting the owner sleep better at night?
 
Originally Posted By: SLO_Town
I mention this because of all the controversy regarding early drain of FF. In my case, it obviously caused no harm whatsoever.

It does, your wallet is much lighter with all those short OCI's.

I changed the FF of my E430 when it passed the FSS by several hundreds miles. The FF and other OCI's should be done when FSS counts down from 10k miles to less than 1k miles, but I was busy at that time and FSS went to minus 400-500 miles.

It caused any harm to the engine ? I don't know, but so far it doesn't consume any oil during 10-13k OCI's, even with thinner xW20 PP, PU and M1.
 
Originally Posted By: CATERHAM
Looks good.

BTW if it's convenient to pick-up, I prefer BMW's own 5W-30 to GC, it's better additized as it contains Moly and Boron.
At 7 bucks a quarts it's not bad.


I prefer oils with boron and moly too, but there's just not enough detergent in the BMW oil to do extended oci's.
 
Originally Posted By: vinu_neuro
Originally Posted By: CATERHAM
Looks good.

BTW if it's convenient to pick-up, I prefer BMW's own 5W-30 to GC, it's better additized as it contains Moly and Boron.
At 7 bucks a quarts it's not bad.


I prefer oils with boron and moly too, but there's just not enough detergent in the BMW oil to do extended oci's.

With only a 2,600 mile OCI I don't think the OP is overly concerned, besides I'm sure BMW would disagree with you.
And if your are right, that's another reason why I prefer BMW's own oil; less detergent to compete with the AW additives for those that have no interest (like myself) in long OCIs.
 
Originally Posted By: CATERHAM
Originally Posted By: vinu_neuro
Originally Posted By: CATERHAM
Looks good.

BTW if it's convenient to pick-up, I prefer BMW's own 5W-30 to GC, it's better additized as it contains Moly and Boron.
At 7 bucks a quarts it's not bad.


I prefer oils with boron and moly too, but there's just not enough detergent in the BMW oil to do extended oci's.

With only a 2,600 mile OCI I don't think the OP is overly concerned, besides I'm sure BMW would disagree with you.
And if your are right, that's another reason why I prefer BMW's own oil; less detergent to compete with the AW additives for those that have no interest (like myself) in long OCIs.



Anyone who's looked at a BMW engine that's run olm oci's on the oem oil will disagree with BMW. If you're not after extended oci's it's a fine oil. My parents used it on 7500 mile intervals in their X5's for many years until recently when I switched them to Pennzoil 5W-40.
 
Originally Posted By: SF0059
Good to see a stellar UOA from my hometown of SLO!

You still have family here in SLO? The county is absolutely drying up. The weather has been absolutely gorgeous; summer never really ended. Weather forecast says SLO will be in the '70s this weekend and it may even touch 80 tomorrow where we live in Templeton. Water has become a really hot topic, because as you know we don't have much here in SLO county. Cambria has less than 100 acre/feet left in its aquifer! It's really turning into a crisis.

Scott
 
Originally Posted By: SLO_Town
Originally Posted By: SF0059
Good to see a stellar UOA from my hometown of SLO!

You still have family here in SLO? The county is absolutely drying up. The weather has been absolutely gorgeous; summer never really ended. Weather forecast says SLO will be in the '70s this weekend and it may even touch 80 tomorrow where we live in Templeton. Water has become a really hot topic, because as you know we don't have much here in SLO county. Cambria has less than 100 acre/feet left in its aquifer! It's really turning into a crisis.

Scott


Yep, my family has migrated north to Paso Robles and they have mentioned the drought conditions. It seems to be a cyclical event. I remember when I was a kid in the late 80s there was a serious drought. Wells dried up, no watering lawns, and Santa Margarita Lake looked like a pond.

Hope you guys get some rain come spring!
 
Our '93 SC400 has less than 100K, I use a 5W-30 and typically look to 5K OCI's: if I change it I use a NAPA Gold filter, if it is done somewhere they use the filter they use (last one was at a Firestone with Kendall SemiSynthetic for $19.00). Have gallons of SynPower and 5+ quart bottles of PP and QS synthetic on the shelf.

Never have had an Oil Analysis done on any of my vehicles: never had any kind of oil-related issue on any of my vehicles. Never felt I needed one.

Never had an engine rebuild done on any of my vehicles. I have purchased used vehicles with engine (top end) and tranny rebuilds but never paid for one myself...

To me, Wouldn't mind buying a used car from someone like this, but really don't see the need to replace synthetic oil with TBN readings around 8... How often and with what is a personal choice, but...

Kinda' like buying a new battery for the laptop because the one in it is over a year old and has been recharged a dozen times: I just don't see the need to wear a belt & suspenders on a swimsuit, either!

Cheers!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom