Much of the last 20 years I had Natural gas. and also growing up in my parents house Natural Gas. About 5 years within-between those two I had oil, and it was ok, more troublesome but ok. Also I could deal with the oil companies competing on Long Island for an ok price.
Than for the least 18 years or so until 2023 we had a first floor HVAC with Natural Gas for heat and heat pump on the second floor. Because heats rises, come winter we didnt need the second floor heat pump often.
Now in our new home of 2 years, we have a heat pump for house heat and propane for hot water, stove top, fireplace.
I H-A-T-E them both the propane and heat pump compared to Natural Gas. I do think I would put oil at the bottom of the list though. I wouldnt want it again.
Thing is, with a heat pump on super cold days like now in the Carolina cost is takes FOREVER to warm up the house from our night time setting. The unit just runs endlessly and I am sure that also shortens the life of the unit. It will take hours and hours to go from a night time setback of 64 degrees to 73 daytime like today when it went down to a rare 19 degrees last night. In extreme cold it will run 15 hours maybe more in a day. Record is 21 hours in Dec.
WIth propane I am STUCK with Suburban and between the delivery charge, transportation fuel surcharge and safety fees. I can get gas for my BBQ grill for less money per gal sometimes.
Example, got topped off in October 2025 of last year, total bill was $118 for 26 gallons, roughly $4.50 a gallon
Feb 2025 $187 for 45 gallons roughly 4.20 per gallon actual payment
I dont know but seems pricey to me.
Heat pump run time Dec and most of Jan
View attachment 321862 View attachment 321863