Why some people use monograde ?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why don’t we have a look at what Ford recommends for the 2021 Shelby Mustang for track use. This would be the perfect place to use a mono grade, right? Have a look at the engine specs.

1BD0C29F-1C1D-40C3-8128-A7DD7D9671B4.png
 
Who uses a monograde? The only monogrades i can find are lawnmower's SF/SG/SH/SJ SAE30 oils.
AFAIK the SAE 30 monograde spec is just a high temperature spec, and that it's entirely possible that synthetic base stocks could produce a oil without VII that could be labeled "30 HD" yet actually be equivalent to 10w-30 or even 5w-30 due to the inherent properties of the base stock. Or the flip side is that today's conventional 30HD could likely actually be something more like a 20w-30, except that they're not actually tested at the low temp for the 30 spec. We just don't know. Or the flip side could be true as well- something like Mobil 1 10w-30 could have no VII and be effectively a monograde for performance purposes.

So with that in mind, it's not so clear to me that multigrades are inherently worse than conventional monogrades.
 
AFAIK the SAE 30 monograde spec is just a high temperature spec, and that it's entirely possible that synthetic base stocks could produce a oil without VII that could be labeled "30 HD" yet actually be equivalent to 10w-30 or even 5w-30 due to the inherent properties of the base stock. Or the flip side is that today's conventional 30HD could likely actually be something more like a 20w-30, except that they're not actually tested at the low temp for the 30 spec. We just don't know. Or the flip side could be true as well- something like Mobil 1 10w-30 could have no VII and be effectively a monograde for performance purposes.
Yes, SAE J300 describes how multi-grade and mono-grade oils can be labeled for grade. The blender has a choice on how to label the product based on the performance results.

But a mono-grade oil with a winter rating is tested at low temperatures. There are single-grade winter oils and single-grade "summer" oils.
 
Yes, SAE J300 describes how multi-grade and mono-grade oils can be labeled for grade. The blender has a choice on how to label the product based on the performance results.

But a mono-grade oil with a winter rating is tested at low temperatures. There are single-grade winter oils and single-grade "summer" oils.
Oh, sure! There doesn't appear to be a 30w though; just a 25w, so I think what I was saying still holds- in the absence of a multigrade winter certification, just about any oil that meets SAE J300 for 30 weight could be so labeled.

ISTR reading on here years ago that there was speculation that at the time, 10w-30 Mobil 1 might have actually been produced without VII, and met the 10w and the 30 specs by virtue of the base oil. That's the sort of thing I'm talking about; in that case, that M1 10w-30 would be undeniably better than the conventional 30HD typically sold.

https://wiki.anton-paar.com/en/sae-viscosity-grades/
 
How did i get into an old thread?

I only use 15w40 and higher in most automobiles.

I might actually change to an sae30 in the 2.slow , I did use sae 30 in the 2.5, why not the 2.slow
 
Oh, sure! There doesn't appear to be a 30w though; just a 25w, so I think what I was saying still holds- in the absence of a multigrade winter certification, just about any oil that meets SAE J300 for 30 weight could be so labeled.

ISTR reading on here years ago that there was speculation that at the time, 10w-30 Mobil 1 might have actually been produced without VII, and met the 10w and the 30 specs by virtue of the base oil. That's the sort of thing I'm talking about; in that case, that M1 10w-30 would be undeniably better than the conventional 30HD typically sold.

https://wiki.anton-paar.com/en/sae-viscosity-grades/
And also the old Amsoil product which was labeled as 10W-30/SAE 30, appropriate for an oil with no VII.
 
Hard to argue with you and your usage. :)

Have to ask though, "you're still drawing down that 36-gal reserve of Delo 400 straight-weight? I assume it's held up well over that period? Shake and pour, eh?"

Thanks.
Holy Crap! It's an old thread!
I ran out of my Delo 400 SAE30 years ago. I do have a few gallons of the elusive Delo 15W30 but now my main stash is made up Pennzoil Platinum 10W30 that was on clearance for $3.68/jug(Cleaned out a half dozen Advance Auto's. ) and I picked up 8, 12 qt boxes of M1 HM 5W20 at Walmart for $1 /qt. I have quite a few of those $7.99 Chevron Supreme 5W30 SB jugs as well.

I should have enough oil for another 12 years.
 
Holy Crap! It's an old thread!
I ran out of my Delo 400 SAE30 years ago. I do have a few gallons of the elusive Delo 15W30 but now my main stash is made up Pennzoil Platinum 10W30 that was on clearance for $3.68/jug(Cleaned out a half dozen Advance Auto's. ) and I picked up 8, 12 qt boxes of M1 HM 5W20 at Walmart for $1 /qt. I have quite a few of those $7.99 Chevron Supreme 5W30 SB jugs as well.

I should have enough oil for another 12 years.
Yep! Set for ANOTHER decade. :)
 
some people have good luck with old style monogrades in mowers. actually even better than modern mutligrades.
i see those are from gr l/ll oils, which may not last long, but chemically works like weak flush. (aromatics)
 
Last edited:
some people here have good luck with old style monogrades in mowers. actually even better than modern mutligrades.
i see those are from gr l/ll oils, which may not last long, but chemically works like weak flush. (aromatics)
Would a modem API SP monograde be a Group I or II base stock?
 
My boat uses 30wt. Specifically says not to use multi-grade oils. Don't know why, but it is sure a pain to find 30w synthetics.
Boat motors (and lawnmower) have a tendency to have fuel dilution more so than cars. Straight grade seems to be less effected than multi-grade.
 
I just purchased a Penrite SAE 30 Mongrade. I’ll probably run it next in one of my cars, which are right now both on Castrol 5W30 full synthetic

Penrite SAE30 Mineral
ColourRed
Density at 20°C, kg/L0.894
Viscosity, Kinematic, cSt at 40°C90
Viscosity, Kinematic, cSt at 100°C11
Viscosity Index113
Zinc, Mass %0.117
Sulphated Ash, Mass %0.67
Total Base Number (TBN)6.5
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom