Which iPhone case for best protection?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: DuckRyder

Not really, I imagine that you wouldn't have one of your expensive clocks on your hip when the dust storm whipped up in Clovis New Mexico, or when you slip getting into your work truck because you're covered in mud in Houma Louisiana or on the ice in Malvern, PA. If you actually want to use the thing sometimes putting it in an Otterbox IS treating it like "the $650 device they are", and suggesting that we are careless because sometimes things happen is pompous, arrogant and self righteous.

Particularly with a malarky disclaimer like "don't take it personal"...

If you want to have to treat it like you are caring around a piece of glass and have the luxury of "baby"ing it while you work good on you, but don't act like the rest of us are less than if we want to stick them in a protective case...



I never insinuated that the OP was careless, but he did openly admit he drops his phone a lot. I don't know if that's due to butterfingers or the nature of his work.

Regardless, YOU'VE decided to make this personal and accuse me of being an [censored] when that was absolutely not my intent. I don't think any more or less of a person because they drop phones. It's your money and your phone.

And FWIW, I do have my iPhone 5s in a case because I know that accidents happen. The case is an insurance policy against those accidents, not an excuse for me to abuse my phone. As I said, I have yet to drop a phone.
 
I have the Magpul case on my 5. It's OK, but does not "hold the screen in" when the phone is dropped. It would be nice if the case wrapped another MM inwards over the screen edge. My screen "pops out" when dropped, on the bottom side.

Otherwise, a good and sturdy case.
 
I had an Otterbox Commuter on my 4S. I liked it OK. Their customer service is top notch. After about 20 months of use, the silicone portion was getting loose -- starting to stretch. Some of the port covers were also ready to come off. I probably could have gotten another free one easily enough, but I've since upgraded.

I recently upgraded to the 5S. I bought the Spigen Tough Armor for it (cheap on NewEgg). I really like it thus far. Time will tell how it wears.

I'm sure others offer better protection, but I didn't want it too bulky.

I also ran a Zagg shield on my 4S, and now a BestSkinsEver on my 5S.
 
Last edited:
The commuter is poorly made. I had it and went through 4 of them via warranty(send pic of case/email). Never dropped phone but due to rips at power connector and headphone jack. Junk

The defender is quite amazing. My wife lost a her iPhone 5/defender out of pocket in her work stairwell. It went 4 floors down freefall between stairs in center and then a flight of stairs bouncing. iPhone rebooted itself and left a minor scratch/blemish in iPhone itself.

IMHO Apple hardware is made incredibly well. Our 4th gen iPod touch cannot get destroyed by our kids. People have their opinions on os(android vs iOs) but if you want top notch hardware/durability apple does give that in devices.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom