I don’t believe it’s either or just more like having both. On a day well below zero with battery pack in car above is useless. Obviously jumper cables are useless too without a running vehicle too…..I have really good cables I have had for 30 years that hang in the garage. I carry this now instead. That way I don't have to risk boosting anyone else - just use the box. 59 bucks at walmart.com
View attachment 190124