Here is the VOA of Valvoline synthetic 5w30 a member said he would like to see. Not bad, I’d use it.
Last edited by a moderator:
Why does this have so muck Moly, whereas the European version doesn’t? Is moly bad for bmw b58 engines?Here is the VOA of Valvoline synthetic 5w30 a member said he would like to see. Not bad, I’d use it.
View attachment 278200
I don’t know the details, maybe @RDY4WAR can chime in… not even HPL’s true Euro oils use moly. Something about the chemistry must not play nice; they usually have higher boron and low-to-zero moly.Why does this have so muck Moly, whereas the European version doesn’t? Is moly bad for bmw b58 engines?
Well that makes sense no benefit, negative interaction. Thank you!No single additive is universally beneficial in every application nor synergistic with every additive package. (including MoDTC) If there's conflicting chemistry, it will move the needle in the wrong direction. Trust that if HPL leaves out a specific additive from a particular formula, it's because they found no benefit or a negative result. No all of their Euro oils are molyless.
I am looking at the Valvoline European 0w-20 and the 5w-30 but both have lower Calcium at~1100 ppm but more Magnesium at ~500 ppm. Any thoughts around this would be appreciated.No single additive is universally beneficial in every application nor synergistic with every additive package. (including MoDTC) If there's conflicting chemistry, it will move the needle in the wrong direction. Trust that if HPL leaves out a specific additive from a particular formula, it's because they found no benefit or a negative result. No all of their Euro oils are molyless.
Maybe due to EURO oils being low SAPS?I am looking at the Valvoline European 0w-20 and the 5w-30 but both have lower Calcium at~1100 ppm but more Magnesium at ~500 ppm. Any thoughts around this would be appreciated.
I am hoping you can help me. I am looking at the Valvoline European 0w-20 and the 5w-30 but both have lower Calcium at~1100 ppm but more Magnesium at ~500 ppm. Any thoughts around this would be appreciated.No single additive is universally beneficial in every application nor synergistic with every additive package. (including MoDTC) If there's conflicting chemistry, it will move the needle in the wrong direction. Trust that if HPL leaves out a specific additive from a particular formula, it's because they found no benefit or a negative result. No all of their Euro oils are molyless.
a way s
Well that makes sense no benefit, negative interaction. Thank you!
This is what I found on the PQIA.org siteMaybe due to EURO oils being low SAPS?