Valvoline or Havoline?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Nov 25, 2006
Messages
454
Location
Tomball, Texas
My sister bought a new corolla and the manufactures recommended oci is 5k miles. I myself am an Amsoil user but that would be too expensive for her at 5k oci's. So I am looking at dino, unfamiliar territory for me. However I have narrowed it down to two oils, Valvoline or Havoline, recommendations?
 
Both are excellent oils. Other members have also seen very good results in the corolla with both Pennzoil and Castrol GTX as well.
 
Havoline seems to have a much better add pack. However the new Deposit Shield Havoline has a different formulation, and the new stuffs performance is yet to be seen in UOA's. But get the older Havoline if you can find it. Valvoline is also decent, some just think it has a weak add pack. But given proper UOA's both will get the job done. IMHO, I'd go with havoline. But if you go for Valvoline, try the regular Maxlife, its a syn blend, and it would be great for that OCI.
 
Quote:


Havoline seems to have a much better add pack. However the new Deposit Shield Havoline has a different formulation, and the new stuffs performance is yet to be seen in UOA's. But get the older Havoline if you can find it. Valvoline is also decent, some just think it has a weak add pack. But given proper UOA's both will get the job done. IMHO, I'd go with havoline. But if you go for Valvoline, try the regular Maxlife, its a syn blend, and it would be great for that OCI.




If the Maxlife does not hav the API starburst using it may violate the warranty agreement, not to mention be harmful to the cars smog equip over the long-haul.
 
Quote:


Quote:


Havoline seems to have a much better add pack. However the new Deposit Shield Havoline has a different formulation, and the new stuffs performance is yet to be seen in UOA's. But get the older Havoline if you can find it. Valvoline is also decent, some just think it has a weak add pack. But given proper UOA's both will get the job done. IMHO, I'd go with havoline. But if you go for Valvoline, try the regular Maxlife, its a syn blend, and it would be great for that OCI.




If the Maxlife does not hav the API starburst using it may violate the warranty agreement, not to mention be harmful to the cars smog equip over the long-haul.




I had a converstatino w/Tallpaul regarding this issue. He said that Maxlife will not harm your cat as they have lowered their phospherus levels and it is also SM
 
Quote:


Quote:


Havoline seems to have a much better add pack. However the new Deposit Shield Havoline has a different formulation, and the new stuffs performance is yet to be seen in UOA's. But get the older Havoline if you can find it. Valvoline is also decent, some just think it has a weak add pack. But given proper UOA's both will get the job done. IMHO, I'd go with havoline. But if you go for Valvoline, try the regular Maxlife, its a syn blend, and it would be great for that OCI.




If the Maxlife does not hav the API starburst using it may violate the warranty agreement, not to mention be harmful to the cars smog equip over the long-haul.




Oh jeez, I made a mistake, you are correct. I completely read over the part saying NEW corolla. My appologies, for warranties sake you must go with the proper oil, most likely SM, needing the Starburst as well.
 
Now days, I prefer TA over Havoline. At $1.68, it's hard to beat! But between the two choices you provided, Havoline gets my vote.
 
Yes, Trop Artic syn-blend is a good value. Dirt cheap at Walmart. And I do believe it meets specs. for newer vehicles. Should do good for 5000 miles.
 
Quote:


Starburst is not required for any warranty, period.




Yet again, I wrote misinformation, didnt mean to write "...needing the starburst", should have been "with the starburst". I don't quite know where my head is today...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom