If you want a good SUV, Id say the trailblazer as well. Used in the very tough terrain and driving profile of the USVI, and seem to have a good lifecycle. Couple to that the great engine, and idiocy of American buyers with respect to the resale of Japanese anything, and it would make it a great deal.
if you want safety, buy a mercedes, end of story. Id rather be in a Mercedes than any other car or truck, at the time of an accident.
JMH