Used midsize sedan with reliable automatic tranny?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: gregoron
Thanks everyone. I bought a car already that’s in my signature.


Congrats and nice choice! Thank you.
 
Originally Posted By: Gasbuggy
Originally Posted By: 901Memphis
2012-2013 Impalas get the 3.6 vvti v6 and newer 6 speed auto. Great combination.




This, solid combo, cheap to run and QUICK.


3.6 is good... but the accessories are problematic and 2 of my 3 fleet vehicles (2013) suffered from transmission failure between 40-50K. The LE (law enforcement) versions were an absolute nightmare, PS and cooling issues when the suspension wasn't trying to break itself.

I personally like the car but it is a real [censored] if it will [censored] out. The one that did not have an issue was problem-free until someone tried to insert a explorer through the trunk.
 
Originally Posted By: Quattro Pete
Originally Posted By: gregoron
Used midsize sedan with reliable automatic transmission?

Charger with the 8-speed ZF trans?


That’s my choice.
 
Originally Posted By: Mr Nice
Originally Posted By: Quattro Pete
Originally Posted By: gregoron
Used midsize sedan with reliable automatic transmission?

Charger with the 8-speed ZF trans?


That’s my choice.


OP already bought a car, about a page ago.
 
Originally Posted By: SatinSilver
OP already bought a car, about a page ago.
And 3 years go.

I did not look at the original thread date. Oops.
smile.gif
 
Originally Posted By: gregoron
I actually ended up with a six speed manual 2014 Toyota Corolla L in my signature. Yes, it is fun to drive as long as you keep the RPMs up and work the gears, which I like doing.

But what happened to the 'auto' requirement?
 
Originally Posted By: SatinSilver
Originally Posted By: IndyIan
Maybe check out the more recent Malibu's 14+? CR has them rated near perfect. For me, once the price difference between the good brand and the off brand gets close to a catastrophic repair, and the difference in resale when I'm done with them is going to be $1k or less, I think its good deal to go with the Chevy and let your money work for you in that time period.


What? CR has the Malibu ranked dead last in their category and the only car not on it's recommended list for that size.

The Impala comes in first place in it's category. Big difference between these two models as in night and day.

CR is weird or deceptive or something, their detailed reliability ratings show the car systems with 90% of them at the highest rating. Then the overall rating is 2/5? for that year? I guess the Accord for the same year has almost no systems below near perfect, but the actual difference in reliability is almost nothing.
 
Originally Posted By: Quattro Pete
Originally Posted By: SatinSilver
OP already bought a car, about a page ago.
And 3 years go.

I did not look at the original thread date. Oops.
smile.gif



Me too. LOL.
smile.gif
 
Originally Posted By: SatinSilver
Originally Posted By: PeterPolyol
2012
https://www.carcomplaints.com/Toyota/Camry/2012/transmission/transmission_failure.shtml


The 2013 Honda Accord is the first year for that generation and gets the CLUNKER SEAL. HaHaHa. Thanks for the laugh again.


Originally Posted By: SatinSilver
Originally Posted By: PeterPolyol
2012
https://www.carcomplaints.com/Toyota/Camry/2012/transmission/transmission_failure.shtml


Yes, watch out for those 8 total complaints. Yet it still gets the Seal of Pretty Good. Not bad for a first generation model. The warranty for the trans has been extended to 7years/150k miles.




Thanks for demonstrating your lack of awareness for sample sizes. Had a hearty chuckle. Let's not even mention how late Toyota is to the game with their 'new' 2012-tier drivetrain, how much more resources and impetus they have than literally anyone else to get it right, and how badly they failed at doing so.
smile.gif
 
Originally Posted By: IndyIan

CR is weird or deceptive or something,

No doubt. As time goes on these 'authoritative' rags seem to be more and more 'under the influence'. I don't think highly enough of CR's moral fortitude to consider them ever-faithful and resistant to proposition.
 
Lol. I know. I already went through an automatic midsize car two years ago - a 1995 Mercedes Benz E320 with 227k miles for $700.

I bought it as a project car while I had my 2014 VW GLI 6MT. Long story short, I traded in the GLI to get the wife a 2017 Golf. I kept the W124 Merc as my daily driver. It was a nostalgic purchase. It took me back to when I was living in France in the 90’s and I got to drive a 1989 W124. I just loved the ride and smoothness.

Anyway, my Merc was mechanically sound after $1k in parts and my own labor to get it to daily driver status. The M104 in-line six engine was clean and smooth. The 4 speed auto transmission shifted quickly and crisply. It also has a somewhat close ratio as the RPM would be at 2,500 on fourth gear going 60 MPH. The interior was in good shape too.

However, the paint had lost its clear coat and it was starting to rust. It would cost $3k to get it repainted and then the rust would eventually come back. Not only that, new repairs were in the horizon for a new cat and muffler, radiator, brake rotors and pads, front wheel bearings, new headliner, etc. I basically didn’t have time anymore in the weekend to DIY it. Oh, did I mention that we just had a surprise baby girl 7 months ago, nine years after our first girl! That’s why the 2017 Golf went to my then pregnant wife since giving birth to a baby is pretty hard.

So, my midlife crisis present to myself was sold for a more practical, reliable, fuel efficient mode of transport. Hence, the 2014 Toyota Corolla - but with a stick! After driving an automatic for a while - and a good automatic at that - I wanted to get back to a manual.

Now, you’d ask why I let the GLI with a six speed go in the first place? That was a mistake. I was complaining about the rev hang on upshifts and that the gearing was not really made for city driving since 2nd gear was too tall going around corners. Anyway, I could have lived with it. The Corolla hang revs as well. But the gearing is ideal for city and highway driving. One positive with the Corolla is that I will less likely get a speeding ticket driving it than the GLI or the Merc. I also get 33 MPG regardless of how I drive vs 26 from the GLI and 20 from the Merc.

So, after a series of midlife crisis purchases and mistakes, I’m back to being practical dad again for now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom