We had one air cooled VW, a 1981 Vanagon, and it in no way sucked. The heat was enough to keep the windows clear in cold weather, although not shirtsleeve warm. The gas heater would have been a good add, too bad ours didn't have one.
The Type 1 is very entertaining to drive, while the Type 2 is a cult classic and priced accordingly. The Type 3 and 4 cars also have a following.
These air cooled VWs had a lot of appeal new in a way that nothing from this country or Japan did. Name some basic cars from either country that are considered collectible today. Oh wait, there aren't any.
But you already knew all of this.
There was in interesting article on Curbside Classic defending the air-cooled VWs and their oft-maligned heating systems. The cars were so tight that the blower had trouble forcing warm air (scavenged from the engine bay) into the passenger compartment.
The solution was to crack open the driver's window slightly.
*******
As far as old domestic and Japanese base models not being collectible, you're probably right, but I'm the wrong guy to ask.
I would be delighted to have the following in my garage (and delighted to have the garage to hold them all):
- an early Corvair (with the suspension mods to alleviate the rollover tendencies)
- a '69 Biscayne with 3-on-the-tree and the big inline 6 (probably a 250 by 1969)
- a '68 Valiant or Dart, 3-on-the-tree and Slant Six
- a '67 or '68 Plymouth Fury I, again with a 3-on-the-tree and Slant Six
- a '71 to '73 Datsun 510
- a '71 to '75 Corolla
- a '69 or '70 Datsun 1000
- a '74 Datsun B210
- a '69 to '71 Mazda 1200
- a '69 to '71 Mazda 1500/1800
For whatever reason, I prefer this sort of car to its sportier and/or more luxurious siblings. At car shows I skip over the bling and drool over the daily drivers. But yeah, I realize I'm an outlier ...