driver's side is stuck with the puck in. Or the pssgrs is stuck out. Or slides are stuck. I have developed a process to deal with calipers on my 528es. I unbolt the caliper and swing it away from the rotor. Then I pump the pedal until the puck is almost out. I take it off the hose and take it apart to clean and lube. I use Silglyde as an assembly lube. Works better and is easier on the hands than brake fluid. I also have a cheap 6" C clamp, the secret is to use it just a bit, Give it some pressure,then tap the side of the caliper to align the puck.I'm not saying this to you, Chris, You know your stuff, But to other shade tree types. I'm not rebuilding, I just clean the crud out, buff everything up with a wire wheel and reassemble. I'm 4 for 4 so far.
The ATE calipers I play with are 25 yr old parts. All metal, in fact the fronts are chrome plated.The seal is on the outside of the puck. if there is corrosion at the bottom by the inlet and the bleeder, I clean out the loose crud and buff up the bleeder ,then functionally it is as good as new. No need to hone. Just as any pits on the pucks are OK . I burnish them to fair out the depressions.The Silglyde freshens up the ring and makes for an easy assembly with no trauma. I've only worked with metal ButIf the puck were plastic and didnt melt, and the seal was OK, whats the big deal?