SammyChevelleTypeS3
$50 site donor 2023
Would not at all be surprising if it is. I would even say a 50% chance these days. Really a shame trying to buy QUALITY anything as of late.
two failed "lifetime" water pumps from Advance Auto Parts
- Thread starter mrsilv04
- Start date
100% chance anything AC Delco is white box. If you want the real deal it's gotta be GM Genuine, but even then don't kid yourself: no one is making an OEM level water pump for a 1999. It might be the "best" level when Chinese manufacturers present a tiered price sheet and ask if you want Meh, Good, Better, or Best....but the original tooling, factory and processes from 1999 are long gone
I had some issues with my daily driver this weekend, and with the holiday and sort of mild weather decided to tackle a front wheel bearing. My first choice was OEM, but couldn't get one immediately. So I sourced a NAPA branded bearing (their highest priced and best quality unit) and installed it. I was pleasantly surprised that they had a significant discount for AAA members, but I'm not super happy about using a box store bearing unit.
During the assembly I found a bad tie rod end as well. I was able to source this from the dealer, so that wasn't bad. Took me all day on Saturday to collect parts and begin disassembly and all day Sunday to repair. After my home alignment the truck drives like new. Should be. I'm into it for about $1000 in parts and a few tools I needed.
I have to mention that other than immediate availability, I've been very fortunate to be able to source most parts I need from my dealers. In fact, I've never been told thing are discontinued entirely and I've bought some odd-ball stuff for older trucks. And I echo the other posters in the fact that the dealer prices are usually very competitive with local part stores. The only source that beat them is Rock Auto, but the likely hood of getting a part that doesn't fit is very high.
During the assembly I found a bad tie rod end as well. I was able to source this from the dealer, so that wasn't bad. Took me all day on Saturday to collect parts and begin disassembly and all day Sunday to repair. After my home alignment the truck drives like new. Should be. I'm into it for about $1000 in parts and a few tools I needed.
I have to mention that other than immediate availability, I've been very fortunate to be able to source most parts I need from my dealers. In fact, I've never been told thing are discontinued entirely and I've bought some odd-ball stuff for older trucks. And I echo the other posters in the fact that the dealer prices are usually very competitive with local part stores. The only source that beat them is Rock Auto, but the likely hood of getting a part that doesn't fit is very high.
I'm presently staring at a Murray CP7160 installed on a Dodge Magnum 4/24. About 10k miles and it's leaking pretty good from the weep hole. These were common once upon a time: 318, 360 and the 3.9 V6 IIRC. That covers Dakotas, Rams, Ram Vans, and other stuff like ZJs that got the optional 318.
Really disappointing -- we know from results it's possible to build a wp that lasts MUCH longer than this
Really disappointing -- we know from results it's possible to build a wp that lasts MUCH longer than this
It's an OEM policy - unless you're the dealer, in order to warranty something, you generally need to have the dealer diagnose it.
When I buy a part from the dealer I'm buying for quality, but I'm also knowingly taking a risk of essentially having no warranty.
Last edited:
Agree. Same experience in my shop.
The O'Rielly unit is worse. You will be replacing it again I am sorry to tell you. I completely stopped using O'reilly's for anything in my shop 3yrs ago. High warranty on their batteries, water pumps, alternators, brakes etc. Maybe they have improved since then but I have been happy with Autozone parts for the most part. They still have issues at times but way less and they back their parts up better in my experience.
I doubt you're the only one, been replacing my LS1 AZ pump prophetically every 20-30K. I point to the COO if the parts guy asks questions. Fortunately it is an easy job, and I get a coolant flush and service the bolts (they are not cheap) in the process. I don't want to get stranded, but I suspect they are getting a bit better and I might push it just over 30K mark net time.
I'm still on my first Jasper though!
I'm still on my first Jasper though!
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2025
- Messages
- 138
VERY true. Its FAR worse for a 33 year truck! (My 93 Silverado)
been lucky with my orielys 5.3 water pump. lasted 10 years and 40k and still not leaking
Reboxed Motorad parts in an OEM box has entered the chat...
The warranty is there for a reason. If nothing ever broke you wouldn't need the warranty, right? But also if nothing ever broke the parts store wouldn't exist anyway. So... buy the best part you can afford and/or is available, do the best possible job installing it you can, and if you need to warranty it, well, you paid for that warranty. Unfortunately you're also paying the cost of idiots and scammers because that's baked into the price of everything but that's a different discussion.
Lots of scammers now, even if it's a small thing. Sometimes when I return my core, the replacement pump does not include the gaskets and I have to re-use my old ones. The ones that are not metal are not worth the trouble.
I'd be fine with shorter warranties if prices would drop, too. Ultimately what they'll do is reduce warranty coverage and keep prices the same -- basically "shrinkflation" in a different form.
Already lots of products that used to be LT warranty are one year. That said, I think a year is a reasonable warranty period for most parts.
