Tire techs: What’s the best balancing AT tire?

Joined
Jun 5, 2016
Messages
706
Location
California
I’ve owned 3 sets of Toyo AT3’s, and they’ve always balanced exceptionally well even when I had wheels with noticeable lateral runout.

I’m curious to see if there are any comparable AT tires out there that balance ans easily as the AT3’s do.

Any experienced tire techs care to chime in? 😁
 
Go to The Official Mike Melton on Instagram. He's probably the highest volume tire dealer in North Carolina. He does lots of tire reviews. His top two AT tire picks are the Toyo AT3 and Nitto Ridge Grappler G3.
 
Go to The Official Mike Melton on Instagram. He's probably the highest volume tire dealer in North Carolina. He does lots of tire reviews. His top two AT tire picks are the Toyo AT3 and Nitto Ridge Grappler G3.
I’ve watched a lot of his vids and honestly feel like he’s sponsored by Nitto the way he constantly praises them lol
 
Last edited:
I'm in SW Georgia and see a lot of Nitto tires on trucks. Besides, he sells many different brands of tires.
This is his tire shop.
https://stwdirect.com/#!tires/search?bp=tire&location_id=32379&search_by=vehicle&size_type=oe
What I think about today is what a few ex employees of Toyo’s GA plant shared, which was that the quality has gone slightly downhill since 2020, specifically at that location because of mismanagement. I was told to always aim for the Made in Japan variants.
 
In my experience, Michelin, Bridgestone and BF Goodrich typically take the least amount of weight to balance. Wrangler, Nito and Toyo always end up taking a bunch of lead to balance.
Interesting as I personally had the opposite experience with Toyo, but I don’t doubt it. I read that the made in Serbia Toyo’s have trouble with balancing.
 
What I think about today is what a few ex employees of Toyo’s GA plant shared, which was that the quality has gone slightly downhill since 2020, specifically at that location because of mismanagement. I was told to always aim for the Made in Japan variants.
You can take the ex employees statements with a grain of salt. Toyo Tire in Georgia is non-union and the union wants in there really bad.
 
Very small sample size as I’m new to AT’s. But, DT could not get BFG KO3’s to balance on my new Frontier last year. Went through 7 of them in about 2 weeks and 5 trips to the shop. Switched to the Falkan Wildpeak AT4W and they balanced the first try.
 
Very small sample size as I’m new to AT’s. But, DT could not get BFG KO3’s to balance on my new Frontier last year. Went through 7 of them in about 2 weeks and 5 trips to the shop. Switched to the Falkan Wildpeak AT4W and they balanced the first try.
I’ve heard great things about the AT4W’s. I’ve considered them in the past but they’re heavier than the Toyo’s.
 
I’ve read the same - Nitto and Toyo have a high number of very consistent tires with minimal need to balance; they now have “touchless” production. Otoh, there are TR or DT reviews with hopeless cases which went back for replacement.

Honestly, the smoothest rolling tires I’ve owned are tied between Michelin primacy (they are soft for sure) and Yokohama G015 - which were so smooth they were like water skiing on a sunrise lake - both sets of which did have normal weights to balance.
 
I’ve read the same - Nitto and Toyo have a high number of very consistent tires with minimal need to balance; they now have “touchless” production. Otoh, there are TR or DT reviews with hopeless cases which went back for replacement.

Honestly, the smoothest rolling tires I’ve owned are tied between Michelin primacy (they are soft for sure) and Yokohama G015 - which were so smooth they were like water skiing on a sunrise lake - both sets of which did have normal weights to balance.
My brother swears by G015’s on his Tahoe. The only thing I didn’t like about them is that they seem to have a somewhat high rolling resistance. But they’re stellar everywhere else
 
My brother swears by G015’s on his Tahoe. The only thing I didn’t like about them is that they seem to have a somewhat high rolling resistance. But they’re stellar everywhere else
On my F150 I went back and forth between the G015 and Contintental AT … what was it the TerrainContact? Or something like that? Both were identical for me in mpg. The Continental was also noted for being a higher rolling resistance tire. That said, both were maybe 1 mpg less than the factory tires (which I didn’t care for). I didn’t think 1 mpg from 22.5 in a truck was bad for the improvements received? Both tires were superior in terms of noise level and dirt traction on low intensity off road (basic trail, yard, unfinished construction site, etc.). I ran the G015s for a couple of years until I decided to downsize to 18” wheels, and then gave them to by boss who ran them on a Yukon XL, not a lightweight vehicle. They served him very well and he got several more years out of them, in fact I think they did better on his heavier XL than my aluminum-bodied ford. In the end, the tread started to just break apart rather than simply wear down smooth, with a total of well over 60k miles on them.
 
I’ve watched a lot of his vids and honestly feel like he’s sponsored by Nitto the way he constantly praises them lol
Agreed. Nittos are not known for longevity either. My vote is for the King of ATs:

1780248668376.webp
 
I used to like the K02’s. The K03’s not so much..
Agreed. Too street. They need to go back to the KO or KO2

If price is not a concern, Toyo M55 is a pretty cool tire, Aslo the BFG HD Terrain....Both on the higher price range.

On my 86 Truck, I have some Thunderer Rangers Ats, and they are pretty smooth. You can hear them, but smooth.
 
Agreed. Too street. They need to go back to the KO or KO2

If price is not a concern, Toyo M55 is a pretty cool tire, Aslo the BFG HD Terrain....Both on the higher price range.

On my 86 Truck, I have some Thunderer Rangers Ats, and they are pretty smooth. You can hear them, but smooth.
Funny enough I saw the Thunderers on my Walmart app today and thought they looked pretty cool
 
Back
Top Bottom