I vote for a good quality analog. I have two Milton analog pencil-type gauges, identical model(model # unknown, scale reads from 5 to 50 psi in 1-lb increments, labeled every 5 lbs, iirc card said "for radial tires"), one is about 25 yrs old
, the other is a few years younger. Bought the first, lost/mislaid it after a few years, bought another after a couple months, then found the first one!
For as long as I've had both, they've always read 1 lb apart- and I don't know which gauge is the oldest.
I still use both, both are extremely consistent- and by the way, if you're new to it, there's a short learning curve on how to take a reading- and have never been tempted enough to buy any of the digital gauges, despite of my love of gadgets.
When I wanted a higher-pressure gauge a couple of years ago, I went back to the same local parts store- and sure enough he had a Milton pocket-pencil style that read up to 120 psi. Of course I bought it- and am confident that if no one abuses or destroys it, it'll outlive me.