Originally Posted By: IndyIan
I don't think you can say that folks farming back then didn't enjoy it, using hand tools and animal power. I'm sure not everyday was a treat but they didn't know anything else, and their work was directly connected to providing what they needed. It must've been pretty satisfying to cut enough hay by hand to keep your cattle well fed all winter, and also satisfying to know how to keep your scythe tuned up to make cutting go easy.
I play around with a scythe, to cut fresh grass for our bucks in the summer. I can make my brushsaw look pretty silly in tall grass for a while anyways. I haven't really got the sharpening figured out yet so I'm not going to cut for hours at once anytime soon but its fun and saves me buying hay over the summer.
In this era of more people losing any connection to the natural world or even products of their own labor, it wouldn't hurt for more people to get outside and do something without power equipment.
Actually, I think I can say that. I and my family are from the Southeast US. My father was born in '39 and much of the area then was still highly rural and poor, to the point were subsistence farming with little mechanization was still practiced. As a young man he picked cotton and corn by hand, and of course all sorts of assorted fruits and vegetables (tomatoes, peas, beans, turnips, potatoes, etc.). They only got a tractor for plowing when he was about 15 years old (before that they used a mule drawn plow) and all harvesting was by hand until he left and joined the military. He can tell you that it was backbreaking labor (particularly picking cotton), in the blazing sun, and that military life in the Marines was a welcome relief to the hard life that he had been brought up with. Yes, there was joy and happiness, but it was in spite of, not because of the extreme physical labor that farm life of that era entailed. By his own account, nobody "enjoyed" farm labor, but it had to be done to keep food in their bellies. He lived the life that the people on that website extol and would never go back given a choice.
If you're an aging hippy or a yuppie looking to "get back to nature" on the weekends I'm sure this all sounds very romantic, but if you have to live this life 24/7 for years on end it is much less appealing. For people that lived this type of life for real, cutting hay for a few hours and then returning to an air conditioned home to sit in a recliner to watch a little TV simply wasn't an option.