I just bought one of the new 2009 Subaru Foresters earlier this month. Very well equipped for the price, base 2.5X "plain Jane" model, 5-speed manual trans. But Subaru has made Vehicle Dynamics Control (VDC) standard as well as four wheel ABS disc brakes (ABS req'd for VDC, duh), Electronic Brake Force Distribution, drive by wire electronic throttle control, and of course the awesome Subaru Symetrical AWD-- the best AWD system going. The new Forester is pretty big for a Subaru, but I'm averaging 25-26mpg around town (suburban/city driving). Forester is an extension of the Impreza layout, so I would expect the slightly lighter weight and more aerodynamic Impreza to do slightly better on fuel economy.
I say buy the Subaru and don't look back!