Sold a parts car with a possibly bad engine

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 16, 2003
Messages
1,021
Location
Northern Virginia
I got a 2001 Subaru Legacy Outback, 4-cylinder automatic. It a parts car. I paid $550 for it plus gas for towing 200+ miles. I got it for the transmission. I figured I could part out the rest of it. I removed the transmission.
I have never seen it ran and had it towed. I don't know what the problem was, it turned over but refused to start.

Ended up selling the rest of it to a guy for $600 or about what I had in it, with the understanding that it is a parts car and is missing the transmission.

He contacts me a week later, saying the 2.5L engine is no good. He says it knocks. I asked him to produce a video and send it to me. He is 1.5 hours away and it's not practical to go see it. He than said it has a span bearing or bent valve and that he has already removed from the recipient vehicle. I ask for proof and he says his word is good enough. He said he feels screwed that it's a $300 car and not $600.

I don't really question his credibility but my question is this, how much is a parts 2001 Outback worth, with missing transmission and potentially bad engine? Is $300 in the ballpark? Does the 2.5L develop a knock, and how would a bent valve manifest itself? If the root cause of the car not starting was broken timing belt, this might explain a lot.

Furthermore, he refuses to show any proof the engine is bad, and removed it from the vehicle he had it installed in (I am assuming a different car) with no way for me to verify it's no good.
 
Assuming you told him that you never saw it run and you didn't represent it as having a good engine, sounds like he got a parts car.
 
He could have started it before handing over the cash, assuming you didn't butcher the wiring pulling the trans. He wasn't that interested. Too bad, so sad.

Plus how do you know he isn't trying to scam you, showing a vid of his old knocky engine and pretending it's your new/old one.
 
Yeah, I'd tell the moron to pound sand. A $600 parts car and he expects a good engine?
 
If what you tell him is true, then it is his problem.

-He has buyer remorse.

-He is trying to make you feel guilty and get a refund.

-A friend said he got paid too much

-The price is what he thinks it is worth, that is why he bought it.

-He is an idiot
 
Assuming you didn't say "ran great before I took the trans out," you did nothing wrong. He has buyer's remorse and wants to pass it on to you.

Craigslist is an alright way to buy and sell things, but you have to keep in mind the worst of the worst use Craigslist too. People who do things like buy a PS4 at Wal-Mart, then return the box full of rocks or stacked paper use Craigslist too.

For me, 8-9 out of 10 Craigslist transactions I have made have been totally problem free, everybody is happy situations. You will run into the "I want a refund on what I knew was messed up when I bought it" people though.
 
The only issue is you engaged the creep, asking for the video. Now it'll be harder to shake him off.
 
You told him the truth and he has no recourse.

He could have had a mechanic look at the engine before his purchase but he decided to roll the dice.

You took the same risk but it worked out on the transmission.

I would tell him you checked around and nobody provides a warranty for a parts car.
 
Obligatory comment about how bad Subaru's are.

Anyway, around here, junkyards pay $400 for any complete car. That's all a parts car is worth, IMO. Consider yourself lucky for getting more than that for it.
 
A. He could be a liar and trying to rip you.
B. Hes a dumb butt.
C. Buyers remorse.

You told him it was a parts car with no transmission, his problem.

Relax its not your problem.
 
tell him straight up you have no obligation or owe him a single thing. the truth will take a few days to sink in, and they will leave you alone.
 
Well you were honest so....Does he know where you live>? Will he sue you for something bogus or will him and his friends drop by? Throw him a bone and give him a hundred. That might defuse the situation
 
Originally Posted By: crazyoildude
Well you were honest so....Does he know where you live>? Will he sue you for something bogus or will him and his friends drop by? Throw him a bone and give him a hundred. That might defuse the situation


As soon as someone like this smells blood, they go for the kill. Bullies! You have to be tough and stand your ground. Tell him to go pound sand.
 
Originally Posted By: crazyoildude
Will he sue you for something bogus


I assume you never titled this thing in your name. If it comes down to it tell him very calmly that you'd go along with a decision from a court of law. Someone too dumb to test run an engine won't figure out how to pull the "push" door to get into the courthouse.

The good news is this guy's such a jerk he's used to dejection, which probably happens 2/3 of the time to him so he'll move on.
 
This is why it is a good idea to put it in writing on a Bill of Sale, make two copies, and both parties sign off on each copy. Then he keeps one copy, and you keep one copy.

On the Bill of Sale, as the seller you put such important details as:

* No title.
* Missing transmission.
* Engine does not run, has never run while in my possession, and may be bad.
* Vehicle is in "as-is, where-is" condition. Once you load it up, it is yours.
* Sale price of $600.

If the buyer reads it and won't sign, then buh-bye.

It goes a long way to avoiding any potential "misunderstandings" down the road.

And if there is some sort of a problem later on, ask the buyer to re-read the details on the Bill of Sale document, and politely end the discussion.
 
Tell him to stick his engine up his can.

Actually, no: do not respond. Do not interactt with him in any way, shape, or form unless he threatens physical harm. (If so, IMMEDIATELY file a police report and at least consider a restraining order.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom