Rental Review - 2024 GMC Yukon Denali

OVERKILL

$100 Site Donor 2021
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
61,204
Location
Ontario, Canada
In the US for a few weeks and we have two rental vehicles:
- 2024 GMC Yukon Denali
- 2024 Expedition Limited

I'll be reviewing the Expedition later this week.

We've had both for approximately a week, the Yukon has just under 8,000 miles on it at present.

Exterior pics:
IMG_6203.jpg

IMG_6202.jpg


Exterior impressions:
Sharp looking SUV. The grille is a bit over-the-top huge, but it's not bad looking. Headlights look good and work even better. Exhaust has a nice note to it and the quad pipes out the rear provide a nice balanced look.

Performance:
For 420HP, it feels a bit lethargic. The transmission programming is typical of what I've observed with GM in the past, which is pulling power for gear changes and noticeable roll-in bringing that power back. Not sure if the Expedition shares the same transmission, but the 3.5L EcoBoost feels considerably more powerful and is more eager to motivate something of this size. The Ford transmission programming also results in a more eager personality that makes shifts more "crisp" an overall feeling of it being less lazy.

The engine randomly vibrates/stumbles when at idle periodically, often when coming to a stop, which is a bit surprising for something at this price point.

Ride quality is excellent and handling feels quite competent, despite the size.

Infotainment:
Really impressed with the digital cluster and screen combo. The menus are well laid out and the screen is nice and responsive. CarPlay worked perfectly and the cluster is quite attractive:
IMG_6179.jpg


Was a little surprised to see some lazy LED's on the climate control digital numeric displays. For example, if it's set to 72, the LED that makes up the front of the "2" starts off dimmer than the others and then warms up to match the others. This was observed by my coworker and pointed out to me and is visible in the above photo.

Wireless phone charging works well.

The stereo is reasonably good, though not of the calibre of the HK one in my SRT or the McIntosh offering in the higher end Stellantis products.

The heads-up display is of course welcome, as I'm a big fan of those.

Interior:
GM calls this "premium perforated leather seating", I think that's misleading. Most of the material does not look or feel like leather, it's more reminiscent of something like MB tex. Only a couple of surfaces really look or feel like leather, the insides of the bolsters and the the perforated middle. The rest is almost assuredly vinyl:
IMG_6183.jpg

IMG_6184.jpg


The wood grain trim looks great, and I think GM did a good job with it. Unfortunately the plastic fitment around the glove box was a bit off:
IMG_6180.jpg

IMG_6181.jpg



Criticisms:
There were a few visible QC issues which detracted from what was otherwise a decidedly decent interior:
IMG_6187.jpg

IMG_6182.jpg


Overall, I don't find it as nicely appointed as the Wagoneer, and the Expedition does not have similar QC issues and performs better.

That said, it seems to be a solid SUV and I understand why these, and their Chevrolet sibling are popular, though I do find the random engine roughness disconcerting.
 
Last edited:
VERY good and accurate review. I also hate the shifter design. The A-pillar gaps, glove box and the steering column cover gaps were known issues when I was still at the plant building them but I see they have not corrected them yet. They are on the "continious improvement" list which basically means those issues are not in the top 10 or even 25 items to fix. The performance you experienced is improved by selecting a different drive mode however it will still retard some at gear changes which I hated when I was driving them for evaluations. It felt like wow lots of power until the shift then it builds back up only to repeat in the next gear. That was part of the intentional torque management programming to reduce abuse and to make the shifts smoother. I am ok with that with normal driving but I would prefer full on firm shifts at 80% or more throttle. The seats, well GM leather is and always has been mediocre and those seats do have more vinyl than leather as you noticed - just a terrible place to save money. You have to pay a few more thousand for the Denali Ultimate package to get the really nice interior with better leather seats etc. When the truck launched it had the best interior in the segment, but I think the current best interior is in the Grand Wagoneer.

You brought back memories! I left in Sept 2022 and after 2 years I am still glad to be gone from GM and enjoying myself so much more now that I don't work 12hr+ days and 6-7 days a week plus holidays.
 
Nice review. I think the programming is different in the newer versions than it was in our old one. My wife’s 2017 Yukon XL Denali with the 6.2 and 8 speed felt peppier all around than her 2024 Yukon XL AT4 with the 6.2 and 10-speed.

I don’t hate the shifter after having it in our 2021 and now our 2024, I tolerate it. I did hate it when we first got it though.
 
I was briefly considering for our next family vehicle. Considering I shift manually A LOT, that execution of transmission commands is absolutely insane. It is like they forgot about it, and then added after someone said: how we will put this in D and drive?
 
VERY good and accurate review. I also hate the shifter design. The A-pillar gaps, glove box and the steering column cover gaps were known issues when I was still at the plant building them but I see they have not corrected them yet. They are on the "continious improvement" list which basically means those issues are not in the top 10 or even 25 items to fix. The performance you experienced is improved by selecting a different drive mode however it will still retard some at gear changes which I hated when I was driving them for evaluations. It felt like wow lots of power until the shift then it builds back up only to repeat in the next gear. That was part of the intentional torque management programming to reduce abuse and to make the shifts smoother. I am ok with that with normal driving but I would prefer full on firm shifts at 80% or more throttle. The seats, well GM leather is and always has been mediocre and those seats do have more vinyl than leather as you noticed - just a terrible place to save money. You have to pay a few more thousand for the Denali Ultimate package to get the really nice interior with better leather seats etc. When the truck launched it had the best interior in the segment, but I think the current best interior is in the Grand Wagoneer.

You brought back memories! I left in Sept 2022 and after 2 years I am still glad to be gone from GM and enjoying myself so much more now that I don't work 12hr+ days and 6-7 days a week plus holidays.
I have many things on my "continuous improvement" list.

This is code for put it off for SOOOOO long that it's either no longer necessary or resolves itself by other means.

"Well, I was gonna fix that eventually, but....." :D
 
same transmission, but one manufacturer has infinitely more issues with theirs. i wonder if the torque management you’re feeling is why GM has lesser issues with the 10l90.
 
I've always found rental cars with non-traditional shifters to be awkward, but feel that if I owned the vehicle I'd get used to it pretty quickly. I think a column mount shifter with up for reverse, down for drive and a push button for park makes the most sense.

I like the looks of the full size GM SUVs.
 
Back
Top Bottom