Originally Posted By: Merkava_4
I thought my advice was pretty good too even though it was bleeding with sarcasm.
I'd agree, Merk. I can't see it needing a 20 grade, at least not an ILSAC one.
Cameradude: There is lots of good advice in here. Shannow makes some very good points. A_Harman's point about HDEOs is worth noting, but I'd add a couple qualifiers. Driving style matters. If it were my driving style in your climate, a 15w40 HDEO would be just dandy. For others, maybe not. A synthetic HDEO might be worthwhile.
Alternatively, if you, for whatever reason, wanted to avoid synthetics, Quaker State Defy or Valvoline VR1 in 10w30 are suitable options, as would be RP HPS. Go with something you like, of course, and spend what you're comfortable spending.
As for ZDDP, well, there are two things to look at. Yes, too much phosphorus will poison a cat, but that's assuming you're consuming enough oil. If you're consuming a lot of oil, it might not matter what you're running, when it comes to your cat. And, you may have cam problems down the road despite running "sufficient" ZDDP. At least a cat won't be expensive on the vehicle, certainly not in comparison to a cat on something new. A_Harman also covers some of the options if something goes wrong.
My big concern (which we haven't seen, fortunately, in this thread) is when we see people pushing a boutique oil designed to work miracles with cam protection, when two oil changes winds up costing more than a cam and lifter replacement.
Ramblejam: When I saw actual error bars on that chart you posted, I just about fell over.