help pick tires for 2021 RAV4

2021 Toyota RAV4, XLE, FWD. 225/65R17. 86k miles on vehicle. We plan on keeping it "forever".
Now, the vehicle is mainly used for road trips; not much daily use. No snow, just dry and wet pavement, no off road at all.
Coming off the vehicle are Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3. When I got them, I did a little research, and they had great reviews, 70k mile warranty, and UTQG of 800.
I have put 50k on them and rotated them 5 times.
There is 3/10th or 4/10th of tread left and they have been howling like crazy since there was about 25k miles on them.
Never again.
I get my tires from a guy that owns a local small mom and pop tire and auto place in town.
I did a little research and gave him a list. He added a couple and sent me back options with out the door prices. Please let me know your thoughts. I have a few other thoughts but want to refrain for sharing any more so as not to taint what anyone else says.
TIA
~
$500 Summit Trail Climber SUV
$670 Cooper Endeavor Plus
$685 Cooper Procontact
$700 Falken CT60
$760 General Altimax RT45
$830 Michelin Defender2
$870 Continental TrueContact
$1010 Bridgestone Alenza Prestige
My most recent tire purchases were Cooper Endeavor Plus on a Grand Cherokee that never goes off roading. Seem quiet but they are basically unworn in the last 6 months (maybe have 3000 miles on them). Seem good have a 70000 mile warranty and a high UTQG
 
There is no cooper procontact
there are conti procontact or cooper procontrol.
2021 Toyota RAV4, XLE, FWD. 225/65R17. 86k miles on vehicle. We plan on keeping it "forever".
Now, the vehicle is mainly used for road trips; not much daily use. No snow, just dry and wet pavement, no off road at all.
Coming off the vehicle are Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3. When I got them, I did a little research, and they had great reviews, 70k mile warranty, and UTQG of 800.
I have put 50k on them and rotated them 5 times.
There is 3/10th or 4/10th of tread left and they have been howling like crazy since there was about 25k miles on them.
Never again.
I get my tires from a guy that owns a local small mom and pop tire and auto place in town.
I did a little research and gave him a list. He added a couple and sent me back options with out the door prices. Please let me know your thoughts. I have a few other thoughts but want to refrain for sharing any more so as not to taint what anyone else says.
TIA
~
$500 Summit Trail Climber SUV
$670 Cooper Endeavor Plus
$685 Cooper Procontact
$700 Falken CT60
$760 General Altimax RT45
$830 Michelin Defender2
$870 Continental TrueContact
$1010 Bridgestone Alenza Prestige
There is no cooper procontact
there are conti procontact or cooper procontrol.
I like the RT45 but the value isnt there at 760.

The falken CT60@ 700 looks interesting.
The defender 2 @830 seems reasonable.

Continental CrossContact LX25 (not listed) appear to be cheap in your size.

tirerack has
Continental CrossContact ATR for 395 after rebate for 4. (what I would get for me)
 
One consideration is the annual mileage may be low, and the tires may age out before wearing out.

Michelin, continental, Yokohama are the ones I’ve personally had best wet highway experiences with, with continental being the best of the three when wet. Yokohama uniformity has been excellent, and probably less noisy over their lifespan.

I generally have a tough time choosing between these three brands.

Pirelli has some reviews of noise and balance issues when they age. Some folks have reported trouble keeping continentals balanced late in life. I find Michelins get noisy late in life. I have had one set of coopers and they wore funny with cupping and sawtooth patterns, rotated by the book.

I’ve had no surprises out of Yokohama as they wear.
 
Funny, while just into reading your first line, ;) I was going to suggest the Scorpion AS Plus3 as I have them on our ‘23 VENZA(RAV’s sister) until you mentioned that they’re coming off of your RAV4.
And since you want to keep your RAV4 for some length of time and not keep repeating/replacing tires and the extra cost of installation each time, I would suggest a slightly higher end tire such as Michelin or Continental. Although the tires on you list are all very good choices in their own right. I can tell that you did your research. (y)
 
Here is my suggestion to add to your list for consideration: FALKEN Sincera SN250

Just read the ratings and reviews on the Tire Rack site and see if it meets your goals and expectations for your application. I just put them on my Jeep (on-road use only) this year and could not be more impressed at any price. It's one of the best overall performing tires I have ever had on a daily driver.
 
Last edited:
Tire Rack Touring Tires Video - seriously watch and write down some numbers for what is important for you. Defender 2 probably lonest lasting but on their back to back, a little stiffer, a bit noisier than others. Not loud but also watch the emergency lane change things.

Snow not an issue but my son just put Continental SecureContact AW (all weather) on wife's Tucson. Of course new but he said quieter than at least the worn Michelin Primacy. I think all get louder as they age also based on tread depth, harmonics, tread to cushion. My Pirelli AS+2 got that way all of a sudden (at least in my ears). The replacement AS3 are silent as compared to them, at least for now. The SecureContact is not directional so you can cross rotate to help even out wear vs something like Michelin CrossClimate 2 or Goodyear WeatherReady 2.

I would also consider the Nokian One.
Continental CrossContact LX25 always got good reviews but older tech/compound at this point.
Vredestein HiTrac
Pirelli also has a new Scorpion AS4


Do not get any Bridgestone Ecopia or Dueler versions.

If you consider what Costco has available if you have a membership, for choices (Michelin, Bridgestone, some Firestone) you get free mounting/balance, flat repair and 5 year road hazard included in the price. That may help on trips if you ever have issue.
Better yet is the TireRack CUV tire test.
The 2024 CUV tire test using the Stelvio with All Season tires
The 2025 CUV tire test using the Stelvio with All Season tires not in the last test
The videos can be a bit overwhelming but certainly worth viewing. I watched them and chose the tires that I did and am happy with my choice for my needs, climate & driving style.
 
Last edited:
CONTINENTAL , $110 Continental Tire Prepaid Mastercard and additional $90 if using Continental Credit Card . Ends 8/31/26

You'll find the list of tires that are available with discounts under OFFERS at their site . 19 are available .
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom