The Fram Sure Drain might be slightly more fail-safe, but finding them is not easy since they have been discontinued. The problem with Sure Drains is that if you lose the fitting used to open the valve, you have to remove it to drain the oil. I lost the fitting for my truck's Sure Drain and I could not find a replacement. I ended up putting a regular drain plug in. Fumoto valves do not have that problem. The Sure Drain did work very well for the year and a half that I used it though.